|
Neck retractions, cervical
root decompression, and radicular pain.
Abdulwahab SS, Sabbahi M
1: J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
2000 Jan;30(1):4-9; discussion 10-2
Texas Woman's University,
School of Physical Therapy, Houston 77030-2897, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: Two-group
repeated measures. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the changes in the
flexor carpi radialis H reflex after reading and neck
retraction exercises and to correlate reflex changes with the
intensity of radicular pain.
BACKGROUND: Repeated neck
retraction movements have been routinely prescribed for
patients with neck pain. METHODS AND MEASURES: Ten nonimpaired
subjects (mean age, 27 +/- 4 years) and 13 patients (mean age,
35 +/- 9 years) with C7 radiculopathy volunteered for the
study. The flexor carpi radialis H reflex was elicited by
electrical stimulation of the median nerve at the cubital
fossa before and after 20 minutes of reading and after 20
repetitive neck retractions.
Subjective intensity of the
radicular pain was reported before and after each condition
using an analog scale. RESULTS: For patients with
radiculopathy, a repeated-measures analysis of variance showed
a significant decrease in the H reflex amplitude (from 0.81
+/- 0.4 to 0.69 +/- 0.39 mV), an increase in radicular
symptoms after reading (from 4.2 +/- 1.3 to 5.6 +/- 1.4 on the
visual analog scale), an increase in the H reflex amplitude
(from 0.69 +/- 0.39 to 1.01 +/- 0.49 mV), and a decrease in
pain intensity (from 5.6 +/- 1.4 to 1.5 +/- 1.3) after
repeated neck retractions. There was an association between
cervical root compression (smaller H reflexes) and increased
pain during reading and between cervical root decompression
(larger H reflex) and reduced pain (r = -0.86 to -0.60).
Exacerbation of symptoms was found with a reading posture.
There were no significant changes in the H reflex amplitude in
the nonimpaired group. No
changes were found in reflex
latency for either groups. CONCLUSIONS: Neck retractions
appeared to alter H reflex amplitude. These exercises might
promote cervical root decompression and reduce radicular pain
in patients with C7 radiculopathy. The opposite effect (an
exacerbation of symptoms) was found with the reading posture.
PMID: 10705591, UI: 20169769
EMG
support of breig
@@1: Spine 1999 Jan
15;24(2):137-41
Cervical root compression
monitoring by flexor carpi radialis H-reflex in
healthy subjects.
Sabbahi M, Abdulwahab S
School of Physical Therapy,
Texas Woman's University, Houston, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: One-group,
pretest-postest experimental research with repeated
measures. OBJECTIVE: To
determine the effect of head postural modification on
the flexor carpi radialis
H-reflex in healthy subjects. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND
DATA: H-reflex testing has
been reported to be useful in evaluating and treating
patients with lumbosacral and
cervical radiculopathy. The idea behind this
technique is that postural
modification can cause further H-reflex inhibition,
indicating more compression of
the impinged nerve root, or recovery, indicating
decompression of the root.
Such assumptions cannot be supported unless the
influence of normal head
postural modification on the H-reflex in healthy
subjects is studied. METHODS:
Twenty-two healthy subjects participated in this
study (14 men, 8 women; mean
age, 39 +/- 9 years). The median nerve of the
subjects at the cubital fossa
was electrically stimulated (0.5 msec; 0.2 pulses
per second [pps] at H-max),
whereas the flexor carpi radialis muscle H-reflex
was recorded by
electromyography. The H-reflexes were recorded after the
subject
randomly maintained the end
range of head-forward flexion, backward extension,
rotation to the right and the
left, lateral bending to the right and the left,
retraction and protraction.
These were compared with the H-reflex recorded
during comfortable neutral
positions. Data were recorded after the subject
maintained the position for 30
seconds, to avoid the effect of dynamic postural
modification on the H-reflex.
Four traces were recorded in each position. During
recording, the H-reflex was
monitored by the M-response to avoid any changes in
the stimulation-recording
condition. RESULTS: Repeated multivariate analysis of
variance was used to evaluate
the significance of the difference among the
H-reflex, amplitude, and
latency, in various head positions. The H-reflex
amplitude showed statistically
significant changes (P < 0.001) with head
postural modification. All
head positions, except flexion, facilitated the
H-reflex. Extension, lateral
bending, and rotation toward the side of the
recording produced higher
reflex facilitation than the other positions. These
results indicate that H-reflex
changes may be caused by spinal root
compression-decompression
mechanisms. It may also indicate that relative spinal
root decompression occurs in
most head-neck postures except forward flexion.
CONCLUSIONS: Head postural
modification significantly influences the H-reflex
amplitude but not the latency.
This indicates that the H-reflex is a more
sensitive predictor of normal
physiologic changes than are latencies. The
H-reflex modulation in various
head positions may be-caused by relative spinal
root compression-decompression
mechanisms.
PMID: 9926383, UI: 99125206
Surgical treatment of cervical
spondylotic myelopathy: time for a controlled trial.
Rowland LP
Neurology 1992 Jan;42(1):5-13
Neurological Institute,
Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY 10032-3784.
Surgical procedures on the
cervical spine are accepted therapies for the myelopathy of
cervical
spondylosis. However, reported
improvement rates vary widely, and many reports indicate
improvement in about one-half
of the cases. It has not been proven that outcome after
surgery is
better than the natural
history or conservative therapy. Radiographic or imaging
evidence of cord
impingement or compression may
be seen in asymptomatic people. There are no clear guides to
the selection of patients who
may benefit from the operation and there has been no
standardization of
preoperative evaluation, trials of conservative therapy,
ascertainment of
progressive disability, or
assessment of outcome. A multicenter controlled trial might
answer
these questions.
Analysis of the cervical spine
alignment following laminoplasty and laminectomy.
Matsunaga S, Sakou T, Nakanisi
K
Spinal Cord 1999
Jan;37(1):20-4
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Kagoshima University,
Sakuragaoka,
Japan.
Very little detailed
biomechanical examination of the alignment of the cervical
spine following
laminoplasty has been
reported. We performed a comparative study regarding the
buckling-type
alignment that follows
laminoplasty and laminectomy to know the mechanical changes in
the
alignment of the cervical
spine. Lateral images of plain roentgenograms of the cervical
spine were
put into a computer and
examined using a program we developed for analysis of the
buckling-type alignment.
Sixty-four patients who underwent laminoplasty and 37 patients
who
underwent laminectomy were
reviewed retrospectively. The subjects comprised patients with
cervical spondylotic
myelopathy (CSM) and those with ossification of the posterior
longitudinal
ligament (OPLL). The
postoperative observation period was 6 years and 7 months on
average
after laminectomy, and 5
years and 6 months on average following laminoplasty.
Development of
the buckling-type alignment
was found in 33% of patients following laminectomy and only 6%
after laminoplasty.
Development of buckling-type alignment following laminoplasty
appeared
markedly less than following
laminectomy in both CSM and OPLL patients. These results favor
laminoplasty over
laminectomy from the aspect of mechanics.
Atrophy of the nuchal muscle
and change in cervical curvature after expansive open-door
laminoplasty.
Fujimura Y, Nishi Y
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg
1996;115(3-4):203-5
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
We analyzed computed
tomography (CT) images and plain X-ray films of 53 patients
who had
undergone expansive open-door
laminoplasty, in a 3-year study. The relationship between the
postoperative changes in the
nuchal muscles and those in the cervical curvature was
investigated.
On postoperative CT images,
the cross-sectional area of all nuchal muscles was reduced to
approximately 80% of its
preoperative size. This atrophic change was especially intense
in the
multifidus muscle and the
semispinalis cervicis muscle. Postoperative cross-sectional
area of the
deep nuchal muscles was
reduced approximately 30% from its preoperative size. No
significant
correlation was found between
the all cross-sectional area of the nuchal muscles and the
cervical
curvature. However, a weak
correlation was found between the deep nuchal muscles area and
the curve index (correlation
coefficient 0.29).
support of breig
Lordotic alignment and
posterior migration of the spinal cord following en bloc
open-door laminoplasty for cervical myelopathy: a magnetic
resonance imaging study.
Baba H, Uchida K, Maezawa Y,
Furusawa N, Azuchi M, Imura S
J Neurol 1996
Sep;243(9):626-32
We investigated lordotic
alignment and posterior migration of the spinal cord following
en bloc
open-door laminoplasty for
cervical myelopathy. Fifty-five patients (32 men and 23 women)
were studied, with an average
follow-up of 2.4 years. Radiological examination included
evaluation of lordosis of the
cervical spine and spinal cord, degree of enlargement of bony
spinal
canal, and the magnitude of
posterior cord migration. We also correlated these changes
with
neurological improvement.
Postoperatively, there was an average of 5% loss of cervical
spine
lordosis (P > 0.01) on
radiographs and 12% reduction in the lordotic alignment of the
spinal cord
(P > 0.05) on magnetic
resonance imaging. Postoperatively, the size of the bony
spinal canal
increased by 48%. Posterior
cord migration showed a significant correlation with the
preoperative cervical spine
and spinal cord lordosis (P < 0.05). Thirty-seven (67%)
patients with
neurological improvement
exceeding 50% showed significant posterior cord migration
following
laminoplasty compared with
those demonstrating less than 50% improvement (P = 0.01). Our
results suggest that a
significant neurological improvement is associated with
posterior cord
migration after cervical
laminoplasty.
PMID:
8892062, UI: 97047142
Multilevel cervical
spondylosis. Laminoplasty versus anterior decompression.
Hirabayashi K, Bohlman HH
Spine 1995 Aug 1;20(15):1732-4
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
Poor overall outcome and a
high incidence of postoperative kyphosis and progressive
myelopathy have driven
surgeons away from decompressive laminectomy as a treatment
for
multilevel cervical
spondylosis. Dr. Henry Bohlman advocates anterior
decompression and fusion
as the best approach to the
pathophysiology of this disorder, while Dr. Kiyoshi
Hirabayashi
believes that laminoplasty
represents an excellent strategy for patients with
degenerative disease,
as well as those with
ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament.
Preoperative and postoperative
magnetic resonance image evaluations of the spinal cord in
cervical myelopathy.
Yone K, Sakou T, Yanase M,
Ijiri K
Spine 1992 Oct;17(10 Suppl):S388-92
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Kagoshima University, Japan.
To evaluate the morphologic
changes of the spinal cord in patients with cervical
myelopathy due
to cervical spondylosis and
ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament, the
authors
measured the thickness and
signal intensity of the cervical cord with magnetic resonance
imaging
in healthy adults and patients
with cervical myelopathy, and compared these findings. In
patients
with cervical myelopathy, the
preoperative and postoperative magnetic resonance imaging
findings were compared with
the severity of myelopathy and postoperative results. In
healthy
adults, the anteroposterior
diameter of the cervical cord was 7.8 mm at the C3 level and
decreased at lower levels. In
the patients with cervical myelopathy, the preoperative spinal
anteroposterior diameter was
significantly reduced at various levels corresponding to the
stenosis
site within the vertebral
canal. In the group with ossification of the posterior
longitudinal ligament,
the minimal anteroposterior
diameter of the cervical cord tended to decrease with
increasing
severity of myelopathy.
However no relationship was observed between the two
parameters in
the cervical spondylotic
myelopathy group. In the group with ossification of the
posterior
longitudinal ligament,
surgical results were good when the postoperative
anteroposterior diameter
was increased, whereas in the
cervical spondylotic myelopathy group there was no
relationship
between the two parameters. In
the patients with myelopathy, a high intensity area was
observed
in about 40% of all patients
before operation and about 30% after operation. However, the
presence or absence of a
high intensity area did not correlate with the severity of
myelopathy or
with surgical results in the
group with ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament
and the
cervical spondylotic
myelopathy groups.
PMID:
1440032, UI: 93068549
Neck and shoulder pain after
laminoplasty. A noticeable complication.
Hosono N, Yonenobu K, Ono K
Spine 1996 Sep
1;21(17):1969-73
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Japan.
STUDY DESIGN: The authors
retrospectively analyzed the prevalence and features of neck
and
shoulder pain (axial symptoms)
after anterior interbody fusion and laminoplasty in patients
with
cervical spondylotic
myelopathy. OBJECTIVES: To reveal the difference in prevalence
of
postoperative axial symptoms
between anterior interbody fusion and laminoplasty and to
clarify
the pathogenesis of axial
symptoms after laminoplasty. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND
DATA: Outcome of the cervical
surgery is evaluated on neurologic status alone; axial
symptoms
after laminoplasty rarely have
been investigated. Such symptoms, however, are often severe
enough to interfere with a
person's daily activity. METHODS: Ninety-eight patients had
surgery
for their disability secondary
to cervical spondylotic myelopathy. Of those patients, 72 had
laminoplasty, and 26 had
anterior interbody fusion. The presence or absence of axial
symptoms
was investigated before and
after surgery. The duration, severity, and laterality of
symptoms were
also recorded. RESULTS: The
prevalence of postoperative axial symptoms was significantly
higher after laminoplasty than
after anterior fusion (60% vs. 19%; P < 0.05). In 18 patients
(25%) from the laminoplasty
group, the chief complaints after surgery were related to
axial
symptoms for more than 3
months, whereas in the anterior fusion group, no patient
reported
having such severe pain after
surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The prevalence and severity of axial
symptoms after laminoplasty
proved to be higher and more serious than has been believed.
Such
symptoms should be
considered in the evaluation of the outcome of cervical spinal
surgery.
Related Articles, Books,
LinkOut
Postural imbalance and
vibratory sensitivity in patients with idiopathic scoliosis:
implications for treatment.
Byl NN, Holland S, Jurek A, Hu
SS
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
1997 Aug;26(2):60-8
University of California, San
Francisco, USA.
Sporadic research reports of
decreased proprioception and balance problems have been
reported in subjects with
idiopathic scoliosis, yet these sensory motor deficits have
not been
addressed in conservative
clinical management programs. The purpose of this study was to
compare both balance reactions
and vibratory sensitivity (as an estimate of proprioception)
in
patients with idiopathic
scoliosis (N = 24) and age-matched controls (N = 24). Balance
was
measured by the ability to
pass a series of simple static and complex sensory-challenged
balance
tasks. Vibratory thresholds
were measured with the Bio-Thesiometer at the cervical spine,
wrist,
and foot. Compared with
age-matched controls, regardless of curve severity or spinal
fusion, the
subjects with idiopathic
scoliosis had similar simple static balance responses when the
somatosensory system was
stable (with or without vision or head turning), but they were
significantly more likely to
fail the complex, sensory-challenged balance tasks when the
somatosensory system was
challenged by an unstable position of the feet, particularly
when the
eyes were closed. The
vibratory thresholds were similar in subjects with scoliosis
and their
age-matched controls, but
individuals with moderate to severe scoliosis (> 25 degrees)
had
significantly higher vibratory
thresholds than those with mild curves. These findings suggest
there
may be problems with postural
righting in patients with idiopathic scoliosis, particularly
when the
balance task challenges the
vestibular pathways. Although vibration sensitivity did not
distinguish
normal healthy individuals
from individuals with idiopathic scoliosis, those with more
severe
scoliotic curves appear to
have a high threshold to vibration. These balance and
vibratory
differences could either be
interpreted as etiologic risk factors or as consequences of
spinal
asymmetry. In either case,
given that curves can continue to progress even into the adult
years,
improving the ability to
right the body with gravity could help maintain the balance of
the spine
despite structural asymmetry.
PMID:
9243403, UI: 97387370
Kinematics of cervical spine
injury. A functional radiological hypothesis.
Penning L
Eur Spine J 1995;4(2):126-32
Department of Diagnostic
Radiology, University Hospital of Groningen AZG, The
Netherlands.
This paper, based on
functional radiological knowledge of normal cervical spine
kinematics,
develops the hypothesis
that compressive vertebral injury can be produced by abrupt
reversal of
curve between hyperflexed and
hyperextended parts of the cervical spine. Reversal of curve
occurs when the main vector of
a compressive force passes between two centers of
flexion-extension motion.
The hypothesis more clearly explains reverse dislocation of
fractured
vertebrae than the current
concept of Whitley and Forsyth of motion of the head through
an arc.
The mechanism of injuries with
characteristics of hyperflexion of one segment and
hyperextension
of an adjacent segment, e.g.,
in certain types of hangman's fractures, is better understood.
The
hypothesis is expected to be
helpful in guiding experimental cervical spine injury, as it
relates
direction of force to level
and type of the resulting vertebral injury.
PMID:
7600151, UI: 95323521
support of breig
1: J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
1993 Mar;17(3):155-60
Reliability of measuring
forward head posture in a clinical setting.
Garrett TR, Youdas JW, Madson
TJ
Physical Therapy Program, Mayo
School of Health-Related Sciences, Rochester, MN.
We believe there is a need to
identify a practical method for determining
objective measurement of
forward head posture. In our study, we determined the
within-tester and
between-tester reliabilities for clinical measurements of
static, sitting, forward head
posture using the cervical range of motion (CROM)
instrument. Repeated
measurements were made using a standardized protocol on 40
patients seated in a
standardized position. The seven testers had from 1 to 8
years of clinical experience.
All measurements were recorded by the same
investigator. The intraclass
correlation coefficient (ICC[1,1]) was used to
quantitate within-tester and
between-tester reliability. Measurements of forward
head position performed by the
same physical therapist had high reliability (ICC
= 0.93). Good reliability (ICC
= 0.83) was demonstrated when different physical
therapists measured the
forward head posture of the same patient. We concluded
that measurements of forward
head posture made by physical therapists trained in
the correct use of the CROM
instrument are reliable. This reliability is
important for determining the
effectiveness of treatment programs. On the basis
of our data, the CROM
instrument will assist clinicians in the objective
evaluation and reassessment of
the patient population demonstrating forward head
posture.
PMID: 8472080, UI: 93230304
1: Spine 1998 Apr
15;23(8):921-7
The correlation between
surface measurement of head and neck posture and the
anatomic position of the upper
cervical vertebrae.
Johnson GM
School of Physiotherapy,
University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
STUDY DESIGN: Repeated
measurements were made of surface postural angles
registering the relative
positions of the head and neck in photographs and of
angles of the upper cervical
vertebrae recorded in lateral cephalometric
radiographs in the same
subjects. For all registrations, subjects assumed the
natural head rest position.
OBJECTIVES: To examine the correlation between
external measurement of head
and neck posture and the anatomic positions of the
upper four cervical vertebrae.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Interpretation of
surface cervical posture
measurement is confounded by lack of knowledge about
the extent of the underlying
compensatory adjustments among the upper cervical
vertebrae that may accompany
variation in head and neck posture. The correlation
between surface measurement
and postural characteristics of the upper cervical
spine has not been reported to
date. METHODS: The association between a set of
angles describing the anatomic
position of the four upper cervical vertebrae on
lateral cephalometric
radiographs and a surface measurement of head and neck
posture, the craniovertebral
angle, was studied in 34 young adult women aged
between 17.2 and 30.5 years,
mean age, 24.5 years. Anatomic positions of the
upper four cervical vertebrae
were expressed by angles relative to the true
vertical or horizontal.
Surface angles registering head and neck position for
each subject were obtained
from photographs recorded on two occasions. RESULTS:
No strong correlation could be
established between the angles taken from the
lateral cephalometric
radiographs measuring the extent of upper cervical
lordosis, orientation of the
atlas, vertebral inclination, or odontoid process
tilt and surface angles
recording head and neck position. This finding was
attributed principally to the
much greater positional variability demonstrated
within the upper cervical
spine when compared with the surface measurements of
head and neck position.
CONCLUSION: Anatomic alignment of the upper cervical
vertebrae cannot be inferred
from variation in surface measurement of head and
neck posture. This is the case
even in those people identified with more extreme
head and neck postural
tendencies.
PMID: 9580960, UI: 98242061
1: Spine 1996 Nov
1;21(21):2435-42
The effect of initial head
position on active cervical axial rotation range of
motion in two age populations.
Walmsley RP, Kimber P, Culham
E
School of Rehabilitation
Therapy, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
STUDY DESIGN: This study
analyzed cervical axial rotation initiated from five
different starting positions
in asymptomatic subjects. The results were analyzed
to ascertain if rationale for
certain clinical assessment methods could be
justified. SUMMARY OF
BACKGROUND DATA: In the assessment of the cervical spine,
many clinicians use assessment
techniques that propose to isolate anatomic
structures by using various
permutations and combinations of the three gross
rotational movements, for
example, evaluation of axial rotation in flexion and
extension. OBJECTIVES: The
primary purpose of this study was to compare the
magnitude of cervical axial
rotation when started from neutral, flexion,
extension, protraction, and
retraction, and the protraction-retraction range of
motion also was determined.
METHODS: Two groups of 30 subjects, one group aged
18-30 years and the other
group aged 50-65 years and stratified by gender,
participated in the study. The
3Space Tracker system (Polhemus, A Kaiser
Aero-space and Electronics,
Co., Colchester, VT), art electromagnetic tracking
device, was used to determine
the angular and linear position of the head
relative to the sternum by
detecting the position and orientation of two sensors
attached to the forehead and
sternum. RESULTS: Analysis of variance of the data
revealed a statistically
significant difference (p < 0.05) in axial rotation
between all of the five
starting positions. The younger age group demonstrated
greater range of motion when
rotation was initiated from neutral and extension,
whereas the older group had
greater range when the motion was initiated from
protraction, retraction, and
flexion. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that
varying the starting sagittal
head position may affect the anatomic structures
involved in restraining axial
rotation. This supports the clinical approach to
range of motion assessment in
combined movement patterns.
PMID: 8923628, UI: 97082392
Incidence of common postural
abnormalities in the cervical, shoulder, and
thoracic regions and their
association with pain in two age groups of healthy
subjects.
Griegel-Morris P, Larson K,
Mueller-Klaus K, Oatis CA
1: Phys Ther 1992
Jun;72(6):425-31
Philadelphia Institute for
Physical Therapy, PA 19104.
The purposes of this study
were to identify the incidence of postural
abnormalities of the thoracic,
cervical, and shoulder regions in two age groups
of healthy subjects and to
explore whether these abnormalities were associated
with pain. Eighty-eight
healthy subjects, aged 20 to 50 years, were asked to
answer a pain questionnaire
and to stand by a plumb line for postural assessment
of forward head, rounded
shoulders, and kyphosis. Subjects were divided into two
age groups: a 20- to
35-year-old group (mean = 25, SD = 63) and a 36- to
50-year-old group (mean = 47,
SD = 2.6). Interrater and intrarater reliability
(Cohen's Kappa coefficients)
for postural assessment were established at .611
and .825, respectively.
Frequency counts revealed postural abnormalities were
prevalent (forward head = 66%,
kyphosis = 38%, right rounded shoulder = 73%,
left rounded shoulder = 66%).
No relationship was found between the severity of
postural abnormality and the
severity and frequency of pain. Subjects with more
severe postural abnormalities,
however, had a significantly increased incidence
of pain, as determined by
chi-square analysis (critical chi 2 = 6, df = 2, P
less than .05). Subjects with
kyphosis and rounded shoulders had an increased
incidence of interscapular
pain, and those with a forward-head posture had an
increased incidence of
cervical, interscapular, and headache pain.
PMID: 1589462, UI: 92270665
1: J Manipulative Physiol Ther
1999 Jan;22(1):26-8
The ability to reproduce the
neutral zero position of the head.
Christensen HW, Nilsson N
Nordic Institute of
Chiropractic & Clinical Biomechanics, Odense, Denmark.
OBJECTIVE: To determine how
precisely asymptomatic subjects can reproduce a
neutral zero position of the
head. STUDY DESIGN: Repeated measures of the active
cervical neutral zero
position. SETTING: Institute of Medical Biology (Center of
Biomechanics) at Odense
University. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty-eight asymptomatic
students from the University
of Odense, male/female ratio 20:18 and mean age
24.3 years (range, 20 to 30
years). INTERVENTION: Measurements of the location
of the neutral zero head
position by use of the electrogoniometer CA-6000 Spine
Motion Analyzer. Each
subject's neutral zero position with eyes closed was
measured 3 times. The device
gives the localization of the neutral zero as
coordinates in 3 dimensions
(x, v, z) corresponding to the 3 motion planes.
RESULTS: The mean difference
from neutral zero in 3 motion planes was found to
be 2.7 degrees in the sagittal
plane, 1.0 degree in the horizontal plane, and
0.65 degree in the frontal
plane. CONCLUSION: We found that young adult
asymptomatic subjects are very
good at reproducing the neutral zero position of
the head. This suggests the
existence of some advanced neurologic control
mechanisms.
Publication Types:
Clinical trial
PMID: 10029946, UI: 99154208
1: Spine 1997 Apr
15;22(8):865-8
Ability to reproduce head
position after whiplash injury.
Loudon JK, Ruhl M, Field E
Department of Physical Therapy
Education, University of Kansas Medical Center,
Kansas City, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: A two-group
design with repeated measures. OBJECTIVES: To
determine if there is loss of
the ability to reproduce target position of the
cervical spine individuals who
have sustained a whiplash injury. SUMMARY OF
BACKGROUND DATA: The ability
to sense position is a prerequisite for functional
movement. Injury may have a
deleterious effect on this ability, resulting in
inaccurate positioning of the
head and neck with respect to the body coordinates
and to the environment.
METHODS: Eleven subjects with history of whiplash injury
(age, 42 +/- 8.7 years) and 11
age-matched asymptomatic subjects (age, 43 +/-
3.1 years) participated in the
study. Effects of whiplash injury on the ability
to replicate a target position
of the head were assessed. Maximum rotation of
the neck and ability to
reproduce the target angle were measured using a
standard cervical
range-of-motion device. Subjects' perception of "neutral"
position was also assessed.
RESULTS: Analysis of variance indicated the whiplash
subjects were less accurate in
reproducing the target angle than were control
subjects. These whiplash
subjects tended to overshoot the target. In addition,
the subjects in the whiplash
group were often inaccurate in their assessment of
neutral position. CONCLUSIONS:
Subjects who have experienced a whiplash injury
demonstrate a deficit in their
ability to reproduce a target position of the
neck. These data are
consistent with the hypothesis that these subjects possess
an inaccurate perception of
head position secondary to their injury. This study
has implications for the
rehabilitation of individuals with whiplash injury.
PMID: 9127919, UI: 97273529
1: Acta Odontol Scand 1989
Apr;47(2):105-9
Natural head position
recording on frontal skull radiographs.
Huggare J
Institute of Dentistry,
University of Oulu, Finland.
This paper sets out to
evaluate the variability and reproducibility of frontal
head position in healthy young
adults. Two posteroanterior skull radiographs of
22 dental students and 2
frontal photographs of these and 24 other students,
taken at a 1-week interval,
were analyzed with regard to head position and
cervical spine inclination.
Head position varied in the range of +/- 5 degrees
with regard to the vertical.
The cervical spine was more often inclined to the
right than to the left. The
reproducibility of the head position with regard to
the craniovertical angle was
1.15 degrees and that of the craniocervical and
cervicohorizontal angles 0.93
degrees and 1.45 degrees, respectively. Any
deviation in the frontal head
position tended to be spontaneously corrected on
looking in a mirror. It is
concluded that the frontal head position is slightly
more accurately reproducible
than the sagittal head position. The use of a
mirror in front of the patient
when recording the frontal natural head position
is not to be recommended.
PMID: 2718757, UI: 89244136
1: J Orthop Res 1992
Mar;10(2):217-25
Trunk positioning accuracy in
children 7-18 years old.
Ashton-Miller JA, McGlashen
KM, Schultz AB
Department of Mechanical
Engineering and Applied Mechanics, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor
48109-2125.
Trunk proprioception was
measured in 253 healthy children 7-18 years of age
using infrared markers placed
on the back of the head and on the skin over the
T1, T8, and S1 spinous
processes. The children were tested for their accuracy in
sensing return of the head and
trunk to a centered, neutral position in the
frontal plane. Whole-body sway
was also quantified during 10 s of relaxed
standing by measuring mean
amplitudes of trunk marker and foot center of
pressure (CP) movements. The
results show that trunk positioning accuracy
improved significantly with
age (p = 0.000). Subjects could position their trunk
in the frontal plane to within
a mean (+/- SD) of 2.5 (+/- 1.1) and 0.9 (+/-
0.6) degrees of the neutral
position at ages 7 and 18 years, respectively. No
statistically significant
gender differences were found. At every age trunk
positioning accuracy was
diminished in the presence of a continuous external
trunk moment (equivalent to
0.01 x body weight x height), although not
significantly so. Neither mean
trunk sway nor CP amplitudes were significantly
correlated with age or sex.
The overall results suggest that spine
decompensation is only
abnormal when it exceeds 20 mm in healthy children and
adolescents.
PMID: 1740740, UI: 92156965
1: J Orthop Res 1991
Jul;9(4):576-83
Trunk positioning accuracy in
the frontal and sagittal planes.
McGlashen K, Ashton-Miller JA,
Green M, Schultz AB
Department of Mechanical
Engineering and Applied Mechanics, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor
48109-2125.
The accuracy with which the
head and spine could be positioned in the frontal
and sagittal planes relative
to the pelvis was measured and compared in ten
healthy adult males. Subjects
were tested with eyes closed, while standing with
their pelvis externally
restrained. The positions of markers, attached to the
back of the head and over each
of the T1, T6, T11, and L3 spinous processes,
were measured to the nearest
mm using strain-gaged flexible beam transducers.
Subjects were tested for their
accuracy in sensing return of the trunk to an
initial neutral position under
different test conditions. Results showed that
positioning was 16-45% more
accurate in the frontal than in the sagittal plane,
although the difference did
not reach statistical significance. T1 could be
centered to within 7 and 10 mm
in the frontal and sagittal planes, respectively.
No significant differences
were found between active and passive positioning
accuracies. Presence of an
external trunk moment did not significantly affect
trunk positioning accuracy,
although it systematically caused overshoot of the
neutral position. Lastly,
lateral trunk shifts exceeding 12 mm may be classified
as abnormal in young adults.
PMID: 2045984, UI: 91259346
1: J Manipulative Physiol Ther
1998 Jul-Aug;21(6):388-91
The relationship between
posture and curvature of the cervical spine.
Visscher CM, de Boer W, Naeije
M
Department of Oral Function,
Academic Centre for Dentistry, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands.
OBJECTIVE: To study the
relationship between posture and curvature of the
cervical spine in healthy
subjects. SUBJECTS: The study was composed of 54
healthy students (25 men and
29 women) aged 20-31 yr with a mean age of 24.7 yr.
METHODS: Lateral radiographs
were taken of the head and cervical spine of the
subjects while standing in a
neutral position. Cervical spine posture was
quantified by the angle of a
reference line, composed of reference points of the
upper six cervical vertebrae,
with the horizontal axis. The curvature of the
cervical spine was classified
visually as lordotic, straight or reversed.
RESULTS: A relationship was
found between posture and curvature of the cervical
spine (p = .006); a more
forward posture of the cervical spine was related to a
partly reversed curvature; and
a more upright posture was related to a lordotic
curvature. Moreover, men more
often exhibited a straight curvature, and women
more often exhibited a partly
reversed curvature. CONCLUSION: The curvature of
the cervical spine is related
to the subject's posture and gender.
PMID: 9726065, UI: 98394128
Erector spinae lever arm
length variations with changes in spinal curvature.
Tveit P, Daggfeldt K, Hetland
S, Thorstensson A
Spine 1994 Jan
15;19(2):199-204
Magnetic resonance imaging was
used to study the effect of different curvatures in the lumbar
spine on lever arm lengths of
the erector spinae musculature. Eleven subjects were
instructed to
simulate static lifts while
lying supine in a magnetic resonance camera with the lumbar
spine either
in kyphosis or lordosis. A
sagittal image of the spine was obtained to analyze the
lumbosacral
angle and to guide the imaging
of transverse sections through each disc (L1/L2 to L5/S1).
Images
were analyzed for lever arm
lengths of the erector spinae muscle (ES) and the erector
spinae
aponeurosis (ESA), the latter
functioning as a tendon for superiorly positioned ES muscle
portions. The lumbosacral
angle (between superior surfaces of S1 and L4) averaged 44
degrees
in the lordosed, 26 degrees in
the kyphosed and 41 degrees in a neutral supine position. In
lordosis, the lever arm
lengths were significantly longer than in kyphosis for all
levels, averaging
60-63 mm (ES) and 82-86 mm (ESA).
The corresponding values for kyphosis were 49-57 mm
(ES) and 67-77 mm (ESA),
respectively. Thus, there was a considerable effect (10-24%)
of
lumbar curvature on lever arm
lengths for the back extensor muscles. The change in leverage
will
affect the need for extensor
muscle force and thus the magnitude of compression in the
lumbar
spine in loading situations
such as lifting.
Commonly adopted postures and
their effect on the lumbar spine.
Dolan P, Adams MA, Hutton WC
Spine 1988 Feb;13(2):197-201
Polytechnic of Central
London, England.
The activity of the erector
spinae muscles and the changes in lumbar curvature were
measured in
11 subjects in a range of
commonly adopted postures to see if there were any consistent
trends.
Surface electrodes were used
to measure back muscle activity and lumbar curvature was
measured using electronic
inclinometers. The results showed that many commonly adopted
postures reduced the lumbar
lordosis when compared with erect standing or sitting, even at
the expense of increasing the back muscle activity.
The effects of flexion on the
geometry and actions of the lumbar erector spinae.
Macintosh JE, Bogduk N, Pearcy
MJ
Spine 1993 Jun 1;18(7):884-93
Faculty of Medicine,
University of Newcastle, Australia.
A modeling study was
undertaken to determine the effects of flexion on the forces
exerted by the
lumbar back muscles.
Twenty-nine fascicles of the lumbar multifidus and erector
spinae were
plotted onto tracings of
radiographs of nine normal volunteers in the flexion position.
Moment
arms and force vectors of each
fascicle were calculated. The model revealed that moment arms
decreased slightly in length
resulting in no more than an 18% decrease in maximum extensor
moments exerted across the
lumbar spine. Compression loads were not significantly
different
from those generated in the
upright posture. However, there were major changes in shear
forces,
in particular a reversal from
a net anterior to a net posterior shear force at the L5/S1
segment.
Flexion causes substantial
elongation of the back muscles, which must therefore reduce
their
maximum active tension.
However, if increases in passive tension are considered it
emerges that
the compression forces and
moments exerted by the back muscles in full flexion are not
significantly different from
those produced in the upright posture.
Lumbar lordosis. Effects of
sitting and standing.
Lord MJ, Small JM, Dinsay JM,
Watkins RG
Spine 1997 Nov 1;22(21):2571-4
Kerlan-Jobe Orthopaedic
Clinic, Inglewood, California, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: The effect of
sitting versus standing posture on lumbar lordosis was studied
retrospectively by
radiographic analysis of 109 patients with low back pain.
OBJECTIVE: To
document changes in segmental
and total lumbar lordosis between sitting and standing
radiographs. SUMMARY OF
BACKGROUND DATA: Preservation of physiologic lumbar
lordosis is an important
consideration when performing fusion of the lumbar spine. The
appropriate degree of lumbar
lordosis has not been defined. METHODS: Total and segmental
lumbar lordosis from L1 to S1
was assessed by an independent observer using the Cobb angle
measurements of the lateral
radiographs of the lumbar spine obtained with the patient in
the sitting
and standing positions.
RESULTS: Lumbar lordosis averaged 49 degrees standing and 34
degrees sitting from L1 to S1,
47 degrees standing and 33 degrees sitting from L2 to S1, 31
degrees standing and 22
degrees sitting from L4 to S1, and 18 degrees standing and 15
degrees
sitting from L5 to S1.
CONCLUSION: Lumbar lordosis while standing was nearly 50%
greater
on average than sitting lumbar
lordosis. The clinical significance of this data may pertain
to: 1) the
known correlation of increased
intradiscal pressure with sitting, which may be caused by this
decrease in lordosis; 2) the
benefit of a sitting lumbar support that increases lordosis;
and 3) the
consideration of an
appropriate degree of lordosis in fusion of the lumbar spine.
Effect of patient position on
the sagittal-plane profile of the thoracolumbar spine.
Wood KB, Kos P, Schendel M,
Persson K
: J Spinal Disord 1996
Apr;9(2):165-9
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455, USA.
Although the normal sagittal
profile of the thoracolumbar spine has been described, this
has been
obtained primarily by using
young individuals standing. We sought to describe the sagittal
profile
of the thoracolumbar spine in
an older population in the supine cross-table lateral position
compared with that standing.
We enrolled 50 volunteers with no history of back pain or
spine
deformity and 50 matched
subjects with mechanical back pain (LBP) only. Lateral
radiographs
of the thoracolumbar spine
(T10-S1) in both standing and cross-table supine positions
were
obtained. Lordosis from L1 to
S1, kyphosis from T10 to L1, and the changes seen moving from
the supine position to
standing were calculated. There were few differences comparing
the two
groups in either the standing
or cross-table supine position, or when changing positions.
Within
each group, however, there
were small, but significant, differences in the midlumbar and
thoracolumbar spine when
comparing supine versus standing. Both asymptomatic
individuals and
those with a history of LBP
demonstrated similar small but statistically significant
increases in
lumbar lordosis and
thoracolumbar kyphosis when standing versus supine. The
clinical
significance of these
findings remains to be determined.
Kinetic potential of the
lumbar trunk musculature about three orthogonal orthopaedic
axes in extreme postures.
McGill SM
Spine 1991 Jul;16(7):809-15
Department of Kinesiology,
University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Many studies have examined the
mechanics of the lumbar spine in various planes, but only a
limited number of
three-dimensional investigations have been reported. Analysis
of the low back
during complex, dynamic
postures demands rigorous representation of the trunk
musculature. The
data of this study
demonstrated the force and torque contributions of
approximately 50 laminas of
various trunk muscles to
flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial twisting torque
at the L4-L5
joint. This analysis was
conducted with the spine in an upright standing posture and
when fully
flexed (60 degrees), laterally
bent (25 degrees), and axially twisted (10 degrees) together
with
two examples of combined
postures. Maximum moment potential, muscle length excursions,
and
the resultant compressive,
anteroposterior shear, and lateral shear forces on the joint
were also
computed. The results indicate
that the position of the vertebrae and their orthopaedic axes,
which are a function of spinal
posture, are an important factor in the reasonable
determination of
joint compressive, lateral
shear, and anteroposterior shear loads. Muscle length changes
that
exceeded 20% of their
respective length during upright standing were not observed
during a full
axial twist, but were observed
in portions of the abdominal obliques during lateral bending,
and in
some extensors during full
flexion. Extreme postures tended to change the torque
potential of
some muscles and influence
joint load. Various portions of erector spinae were observed
to have
appreciable potential to
generate torque about all three orthopaedic axes. This
observation
supports the notion held by
some therapists that conditioning of the erector spinae is of
utmost
importance.
On neck muscle activity and
load reduction in sitting postures. An electromyographic and
biomechanical study with applications in ergonomics and
rehabilitation.
Schuldt K
Scand J Rehabil Med Suppl
1988;19:1-49
Department of Physical
Medicine and Rehabilitation Karolinska Institute, Stockholm,
Sweden.
In this study of the
biomechanics and muscular function of the cervical spine,
skilled women
workers simulated standardized
electromechanical assembly work in eight sitting postures.
Normalized electromyography
was used to quantify activity in neck-and-shoulder muscles.
With
the whole spine flexed, muscle
activity in the cervical erector spinae, trapezius and
thoracic
erector spinae muscles was
higher than when the whole spine was straight and vertical.
The
posture with the trunk
slightly inclined backward and neck vertical gave the lowest
activity levels.
Flexed neck compared to
vertical neck gave higher activity in the cervical erector
spinae. Work
with abducted arm gave high
neck muscle activity. Work postures can thus be optimized to
diminish neck muscle load. Two
ergonomic acids were studied during the work cycle. Elbow
support reduced the activity
in the trapezius and thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids muscles
in the
posture with the whole spine
flexed and in the posture with the whole spine vertical. Arm
suspension gave mainly similar
reduction in these postures, and also a reduction in the
cervical
erector spinae. In the
position with the trunk slightly inclined backward, arm
suspension gave a
reduction in the trapezius.
These findings indicate that arm support or arm suspension can
be used
to reduce neck muscle load.
Three methodological studies related to neck muscle load and
normalization were included.
1) Examination of the effect of different isometric maximum
test
contractions on neck muscles
showed that all contractions activated all muscles studied,
including
those on the contralateral
side, to some extent and at various levels. The highest
frequency of
attained maximum levels was:
for neck extension, in cervical erector spinae; for cervical
spinae
lateral flexion, in splenius
and levator scapulae; for arm abduction, in trapezius, and,
for shoulder
elevation and scapular
retraction/elevation, in thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids.
Proximal
resistance gave higher
activity than distal. 2) The relationship between EMG activity
and muscular
moment was studied in women
during submaximal and maximum isometric neck extension. The
relationship found was
non-linear, with greater increase in activity at high moments
in the
posterior neck muscles
studied. The slightly flexed cervical spine position induced a
higher level
of activity in erector spinae
cervicalis than did the neutral position for a given relative
muscular
moment. 3) Muscular activity
was related to cervical spine position during maximum
isometric
neck extension. Peak activity
in the cervical erector spinae was found in the slightly
flexed
lower-cervical spine position.
Intensity and character of
pain and muscular activity levels elicited by maintained
extreme flexion position of the lower-cervical-upper-thoracic
spine.
Harms-Ringdahl K, Ekholm
J Scand J Rehabil Med
1986;18(3):117-26
The aim of this study was to
find out whether maintained extreme flexion position of
the lower-cervical-upper-thoracic spine
in a sitting posture could induce pain, and thus possibly
play a role in work related disorders
with cervico-brachial pain. Ten healthy subjects assessed
pain intensity of
experimentally-induced pain on a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).
The quality and location of the pain
was indicated on a drawing of the body. The load moment
induced by the weight of the
head-and-neck was calculated. The EMG activity levels were
recorded from the splenius, thoracic
erector spinae-rhomboid, and descending part of trapezius
muscles. This posture, which resembles
the posture in some common work, caused pain in all subjects.
The pain was experienced within 15 min,
increased with time, disappeared within 15 min after the
end of provocation, but was again
experienced by nine subjects the same evening or next
morning and lasted up to four days. The
primary location was in the dorsal part of the lower cervical
and upper thoracic spine; three
subjects also reported pain in the arms and one in the head.
The recorded EMG levels were very low,
but they increased somewhat during provocation. It
is suggested that thorough recordings
of work postures should be included in ergonomic analyses
to provide a basis for the avoidance of
such positions which might provoke pain.
Influence of head position on
dorsal neck muscle efficiency.
Mayoux-Benhamou MA, Revel M
Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol
1993 Apr-May;33(3):161-6
Department of rehabilitation,
Hopital Cochin, Paris, France.
The aim of this study was to
assess the influence of head position on dorsal neck
muscle efficiency in the sagittal
plane. Fifteen subjects participated. The EMG versus isometric
extension moment of dorsal neck muscles
was studied in neutral (with subject gazing on a horizontal
plane), cervical flexed, and cervical
extended positions. A vectorial construction was created by
means of photographs to calculate the
extension moment which balances measured pulling force
and gravitational force in isometric
conditions. The maximum extension was highest in neutral
position. The EMG/moment relationship
was non-linear. The ratio between the EMG and the
generated moment differed significantly
in the three positions (p < 0.01) and was lower in neutral
position. These results demonstrate the
influence of head position on dorsal neck muscle
efficiency; muscles appeared most
efficient in neutral position. Muscle length, depending on
head position, is probably the main
influencing factor.
PMID:
8495657, UI: 93265827
Genioglossi muscle activity in
response to changes in anterior/neutral head posture.
Milidonis MK, Kraus SL, Segal
RL, Widmer CG
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop
1993 Jan;103(1):39-44
Orthopaedic Clinical
Specialist, Rehab Services, Akron City Hospital, Ohio.
Clinicians have acknowledged swallowing, tongue activity, and
head posture as interdependent variables that must be
concurrently examined. The purpose of this study was to
evaluate genioglossus activity during
swallowing, rest, and maximal tongue protrusion in two
head positions (HPs) with a noninvasive
recording device. Eight Angle Class I subjects
were evaluated. Repeated measures were
performed in a single session to record surface intraoral
electromyographic (EMG) activity of the genioglossus muscles.
Head position was measured in angular
degrees from photographs. Three variables were measured in
both the neutral-head position (NHP)
and anterior-head position (AHP): (1) duration of genioglossus
EMG during swallowing, (2) genioglossus
EMG with the tongue at rest, and (3) genioglossus EMG
during maximal isometric tongue
protrusion. A Wilcoxin matched-pair signed-rank statistic was
used for EMG analysis, and a paired
sample t test statistic was used for head posture analysis.
The angles measured for NHP and AHP
within each subject were significantly different verifying
two different head positions. Duration
of swallowing was not significantly different between
head positions. Resting genioglossus
EMG and maximal isometric genioglossus EMG were
statistically greater in the AHP. The
data suggest that head positional changes may have an effect
on genioglossus muscle activation
thresholds. However, small differences in resting EMG
activity between head positions
suggests that the clinical significance needs further
investigation.
Influence of muscle
morphometry and moment arms on the moment-generating capacity
of human neck muscles.
Vasavada AN, Li S, Delp SL
Spine 1998 Feb
15;23(4):412-22
Department of Biomedical
Engineering, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: The function of
neck muscles was quantified by incorporating
experimentally measured morphometric
parameters into a three-dimensional biomechanical
model. OBJECTIVE: To analyze how muscle
morphometry and moment arms influence moment-generating
capacity of human neck muscles in physiologic ranges of
motion. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Previous biomechanical
analyses of the head-neck system have used simplified
representations of the musculoskeletal anatomy. The force-
and moment-generating properties of individual neck muscles
have not been reported. METHODS: A computer graphics model
was developed that incorporates detailed neck muscle
morphometric data into a model of cervical musculoskeletal
anatomy and intervertebral kinematics. Moment arms and
force-generating capacity of neck muscles were calculated for
a range of head positions. RESULTS: With the head in the
upright neutral position, the muscles with the
largest moment arms and
moment-generating capacities are sternocleidomastoid in
flexion and lateral bending,
semispinalis capitis and splenius capitis in extension, and
trapezius in axial rotation. The moment
arms of certain neck muscles (e.g., rectus capitis posterior
major in axial rotation) change
considerably in the physiologic range of motion. Most neck
muscles maintain at least 80% of their
peak force-generating capacity throughout the range of motion;
however, the force-generating apacities of muscles with
large moment arms and/or short fascicles (e.g., splenius
capitis) vary substantially with head posture. CONCLUSION:
These results quantify the contributions of individual neck
muscles to moment-generating capacity and demonstrate that
variations in force-generating capacity and moment arm
throughout the range of motion can alter muscle
moment-generating capacities.
[Electromyographic study on
the effects of head position to head and neck muscles].
Omae T, Inoue S, Saito O,
Ishii H, Ishigaki S, Okuda T, Nakamura T, Akanishi M,
Maruyama T
Nippon Hotetsu Shika Gakkai
Zasshi 1989 Apr;33(2):352-8
The purpose of this study is
to reveal the relationship between the head position, and the
neck
and head muscles. At 4 head
positions, the activities of masseter, anterior temporal,
anterior
digastric, sternocleidomastoid
and trapezius muscle of ten normal subjects standing straight
were
investigated
electromyographically with surface electrodes during voluntary
maximal clenching in
centric occlusion. Head
positions were right tilting, left tilting, up-right and
natural head position.
The results obtained were as
follows; 1. During head tilting, the activities of anterior
digastric and sternocleidomastoid muscle
on the tilting side were increased, the activities of masseter
and trapezius muscle on the opposite
side of the tilting side were increased, the activity of the
anterior temporal muscle did not vary
from the activity during up-right head position. 2. During
natural head position, only the
activity of sternocleidomastoid muscle on the natural tilting
side was increased.
Selective electromyography of
dorsal neck muscles in humans.
Mayoux-Benhamou MA, Revel M,
Vallee C
Brain Res 1997
Feb;113(2):353-60
Laboratoire d'Exploration de
l'Appareil Locomoteur et d'Evaluation du Handicap, Universite
Paris V, Hopital Cochin, France.
The patterns of activation of
splenius capitis, semispinalis capitis, transversospinalis,
and levator
scapulae muscles were studied
during various head-neck positions, movements, and
isometric tests in 19 healthy human
subjects. Myoelectric activities were recorded with
intramuscular bipolar wire electrodes.
Cervical computerized tomography of each subject was
performed before the electromyography
session in order to guide electrode insertion. Head motion
was recorded using an electromechanical
device. This report demonstrates that head motion
results from a complex interaction of
active muscular forces, passive ligamentous forces, and
gravity. Splenius capitis has two main
functions, i.e., cervical extension and ipsilateral rotation.
Semi spinalis capitis and the
transversospinalis are mainly extensors, and levator scapulae
acts primarily on the shoulder girdle.
Splenius capitis, semispinalis capitis, and transversospinalis
play a subordinate part in ipsilateral
tilting. In addition, most subjects' semispinalis capitis were
gradually recruited during ipsilateral
rotation. No signal was detected from the transversospinalis
during rotation tests.
Can stress-related shoulder
and neck pain develop independently of muscle activity?
Vasseljen O Jr, Westgaard RH
Pain 1996 Feb;64(2):221-30
Division of Organization and
Work Science, Norwegian Institute of Technology, University
of Trondheim, Norway.
A case-control designed was
used to investigate associations and interactions between
muscle activity measured by surface
electromyography (EMG) in the upper trapezius muscle
and subjectively reported risk factors
in workers with and without shoulder and neck pain. EMG
data were collected both in the
workplace (indicating vocational muscle activity) and in a
laboratory setting (indicating
non-specific muscle activity). Women in manual (15 pairs) and
office (24 pairs) work were included.
The pairs were matched on age, gender and on current and
historical work load, such as working
hours, type and length of employment. Previous reports of this
study have indicated that shoulder and
neck myalgia was associated with increased muscle activity for
the manual workers, and with
psychological and psychosocial factors for the office workers.
These risk factors were in the present
report used as the basis for studying associations and
interactions between muscle activity
(1), psychological and psychosocial factors (2), and shoulder
and neck pain (3). Subjectively
reported or perceived general tension, a stress symptom
presumed related to psychosocial and
psychological factors, was previously found to be the
strongest and only variable separating
cases and controls in both work groups. In this paper, no
relationship was found between
perceived general tension and EMG variables for the office
workers. For the manual workers a
strong interaction was found; perceived general tension
correlated positively with EMG
variables for the controls, and negatively with EMG variables
for the cases. It is hypothesised that
the feeling of general tension represents a physiological
activation response that may or may not
include muscle fibre activation. This implies that pain
provoked by psychosocial stress factors
may not be mediated through increased muscle activity.
1: Int J Rehabil Res 1999
Sep;22(3):207-14
Treatment based on H-reflexes
testing improves disability status in patients
with cervical radiculopathy.
Abdulwahab SS
Texas Woman's University
School of Physical Therapy, Houston, USA.
BACKGROUND: Postural
modification in patients with lumbosacral radiculopathy
either causes further H-reflex
suppression, indicating increased root
compression, or it effects
recovery, indicating decompression of the spinal
root. The posture that effects
maximum recovery of the H-reflex amplitude is
called optimum spinal posture
(OSP) and is suggested as a therapeutic exercise
to decompress the compromised
nerve root. The focus of this study was to
identify the OSP that effects
the maximum recovery of the flexor carpi radialis
(FCR) H-reflex and to study
its effect on the disability status in patients with
cervical radiculopathy.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Fourteen patients (46 +/- 12 y)
with confirmed symptoms of C7
radiculopathy for the previous 6 months
volunteered for the study. The
FCR H-reflex was elicited by electrical
stimulation of the median
nerve at the cubital fossa (0.5 ms, 0.2 pps at H-max).
Signals from the FCR muscle
were recorded using a Cadwell 5200A EMG unit. The
FCR H-reflex was recorded in
natural sitting position with the head in natural
position and in the OSP. Four
traces of the H-reflex were recorded and averaged.
The disability status was
evaluated, using the Neck Disability Index (NDI),
before exercising in the OSP
and after 2 days of exercise in the OSP. DATA
ANALYSIS: Paired t-test and
Spearman's correlation coefficients were used.
RESULTS: The H-reflex
amplitude and latency were significantly different in the
OSP and with the head in a
natural position (P < 0.004; P < 0.011). Larger
reflex amplitude and shorter
latency were recorded in the OSP. The NDI scores
were considerably improved
after exercising in the OSP (P < 0.001). Spearman's
correlation coefficient showed
negative association between the H-reflex
amplitude and the NDI scores
(r = -0.64 to -0.54; P < 0.05). CONCLUSION:
Exercising in the OSP
increased the H-reflex amplitude and decreased latency of
the compromised cervical root.
It resulted in decreasing the disability status
in this group of patients.
PMID: 10839674, UI: 20296484
1: J Vestib Res 1996
Nov-Dec;6(6):439-53
Effects of different
treatments on postural performance in patients with
cervical root compression. A
randomized prospective study assessing the
importance of the neck in
postural control.
Persson L, Karlberg M,
Magnusson M
Department of Neurosurgery,
University Hospital, Lund, Sweden.
Patients with cervical root
compression were used as a "model" to investigate
the possible importance of
neck disorders and cervical sensory information in
postural control. We assessed
postural performance with posturography before and
after treatment in 71
consecutive patients with MRI-verified cervical root
compression without medullary
compression. The patients were randomized to
surgery (n = 22),
physiotherapy (n = 24) or treatment with cervical collars (n =
25). There were no differences
in postural performance or pain intensity between
the groups before treatment.
After treatment, the surgery group manifested
significant improved postural
performance and reduced neck pain scores, as
compared to the two
conservative treatment groups, and their postural
performance had improved to
the same level manifested by healthy controls. The
conservative treatment groups
manifested no consistent significant changes in
postural performance or pain
scores. Decreased muscular tension due to reduction
of cervical pain after surgery
and normalization of cervical proprioception are
suggested as possible
explanations of the improved postural control.
Publication Types:
Clinical trial
Randomized controlled trial
PMID: 8968971, UI: 97123724
Erector spinae lever arm
length variations with changes in spinal curvature.
Tveit P, Daggfeldt K, Hetland
S, Thorstensson A
Spine 1994 Jan
15;19(2):199-204
Magnetic resonance imaging was
used to study the effect of different curvatures in the lumbar
spine on lever arm lengths of
the erector spinae musculature. Eleven subjects were
instructed to
simulate static lifts while
lying supine in a magnetic resonance camera with the lumbar
spine either
in kyphosis or lordosis. A
sagittal image of the spine was obtained to analyze the
lumbosacral
angle and to guide the imaging
of transverse sections through each disc (L1/L2 to L5/S1).
Images
were analyzed for lever arm
lengths of the erector spinae muscle (ES) and the erector
spinae
aponeurosis (ESA), the latter
functioning as a tendon for superiorly positioned ES muscle
portions. The lumbosacral
angle (between superior surfaces of S1 and L4) averaged 44
degrees
in the lordosed, 26 degrees in
the kyphosed and 41 degrees in a neutral supine position. In
lordosis, the lever arm
lengths were significantly longer than in kyphosis for all
levels, averaging
60-63 mm (ES) and 82-86 mm (ESA).
The corresponding values for kyphosis were 49-57 mm
(ES) and 67-77 mm (ESA),
respectively. Thus, there was a considerable effect (10-24%)
of
lumbar curvature on lever arm
lengths for the back extensor muscles. The change in leverage
will
affect the need for extensor
muscle force and thus the magnitude of compression in the
lumbar
spine in loading situations
such as lifting.
Commonly adopted postures and
their effect on the lumbar spine.
Dolan P, Adams MA, Hutton WC
Spine 1988 Feb;13(2):197-201
Polytechnic of Central
London, England.
The activity of the erector
spinae muscles and the changes in lumbar curvature were
measured in
11 subjects in a range of
commonly adopted postures to see if there were any consistent
trends.
Surface electrodes were used
to measure back muscle activity and lumbar curvature was
measured using electronic
inclinometers. The results showed that many commonly adopted
postures reduced the lumbar
lordosis when compared with erect standing or sitting, even at
the expense of increasing the back muscle activity.
The effects of flexion on the
geometry and actions of the lumbar erector spinae.
Macintosh JE, Bogduk N, Pearcy
MJ
Spine 1993 Jun 1;18(7):884-93
Faculty of Medicine,
University of Newcastle, Australia.
A modeling study was
undertaken to determine the effects of flexion on the forces
exerted by the
lumbar back muscles.
Twenty-nine fascicles of the lumbar multifidus and erector
spinae were
plotted onto tracings of
radiographs of nine normal volunteers in the flexion position.
Moment
arms and force vectors of each
fascicle were calculated. The model revealed that moment arms
decreased slightly in length
resulting in no more than an 18% decrease in maximum extensor
moments exerted across the
lumbar spine. Compression loads were not significantly
different
from those generated in the
upright posture. However, there were major changes in shear
forces,
in particular a reversal from
a net anterior to a net posterior shear force at the L5/S1
segment.
Flexion causes substantial
elongation of the back muscles, which must therefore reduce
their
maximum active tension.
However, if increases in passive tension are considered it
emerges that
the compression forces and
moments exerted by the back muscles in full flexion are not
significantly different from
those produced in the upright posture.
Lumbar lordosis. Effects of
sitting and standing.
Lord MJ, Small JM, Dinsay JM,
Watkins RG
Spine 1997 Nov 1;22(21):2571-4
Kerlan-Jobe Orthopaedic
Clinic, Inglewood, California, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: The effect of
sitting versus standing posture on lumbar lordosis was studied
retrospectively by
radiographic analysis of 109 patients with low back pain.
OBJECTIVE: To
document changes in segmental
and total lumbar lordosis between sitting and standing
radiographs. SUMMARY OF
BACKGROUND DATA: Preservation of physiologic lumbar
lordosis is an important
consideration when performing fusion of the lumbar spine. The
appropriate degree of lumbar
lordosis has not been defined. METHODS: Total and segmental
lumbar lordosis from L1 to S1
was assessed by an independent observer using the Cobb angle
measurements of the lateral
radiographs of the lumbar spine obtained with the patient in
the sitting
and standing positions.
RESULTS: Lumbar lordosis averaged 49 degrees standing and 34
degrees sitting from L1 to S1,
47 degrees standing and 33 degrees sitting from L2 to S1, 31
degrees standing and 22
degrees sitting from L4 to S1, and 18 degrees standing and 15
degrees
sitting from L5 to S1.
CONCLUSION: Lumbar lordosis while standing was nearly 50%
greater
on average than sitting lumbar
lordosis. The clinical significance of this data may pertain
to: 1) the
known correlation of increased
intradiscal pressure with sitting, which may be caused by this
decrease in lordosis; 2) the
benefit of a sitting lumbar support that increases lordosis;
and 3) the
consideration of an
appropriate degree of lordosis in fusion of the lumbar spine.
Effect of patient position on
the sagittal-plane profile of the thoracolumbar spine.
Wood KB, Kos P, Schendel M,
Persson K
: J Spinal Disord 1996
Apr;9(2):165-9
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455, USA.
Although the normal sagittal
profile of the thoracolumbar spine has been described, this
has been
obtained primarily by using
young individuals standing. We sought to describe the sagittal
profile
of the thoracolumbar spine in
an older population in the supine cross-table lateral position
compared with that standing.
We enrolled 50 volunteers with no history of back pain or
spine
deformity and 50 matched
subjects with mechanical back pain (LBP) only. Lateral
radiographs
of the thoracolumbar spine
(T10-S1) in both standing and cross-table supine positions
were
obtained. Lordosis from L1 to
S1, kyphosis from T10 to L1, and the changes seen moving from
the supine position to
standing were calculated. There were few differences comparing
the two
groups in either the standing
or cross-table supine position, or when changing positions.
Within
each group, however, there
were small, but significant, differences in the midlumbar and
thoracolumbar spine when
comparing supine versus standing. Both asymptomatic
individuals and
those with a history of LBP
demonstrated similar small but statistically significant
increases in
lumbar lordosis and
thoracolumbar kyphosis when standing versus supine. The
clinical
significance of these
findings remains to be determined.
Kinetic potential of the
lumbar trunk musculature about three orthogonal orthopaedic
axes in extreme postures.
McGill SM
Spine 1991 Jul;16(7):809-15
Department of Kinesiology,
University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Many studies have examined the
mechanics of the lumbar spine in various planes, but only a
limited number of
three-dimensional investigations have been reported. Analysis
of the low back
during complex, dynamic
postures demands rigorous representation of the trunk
musculature. The
data of this study
demonstrated the force and torque contributions of
approximately 50 laminas of
various trunk muscles to
flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial twisting torque
at the L4-L5
joint. This analysis was
conducted with the spine in an upright standing posture and
when fully
flexed (60 degrees), laterally
bent (25 degrees), and axially twisted (10 degrees) together
with
two examples of combined
postures. Maximum moment potential, muscle length excursions,
and
the resultant compressive,
anteroposterior shear, and lateral shear forces on the joint
were also
computed. The results indicate
that the position of the vertebrae and their orthopaedic axes,
which are a function of spinal
posture, are an important factor in the reasonable
determination of
joint compressive, lateral
shear, and anteroposterior shear loads. Muscle length changes
that
exceeded 20% of their
respective length during upright standing were not observed
during a full
axial twist, but were observed
in portions of the abdominal obliques during lateral bending,
and in
some extensors during full
flexion. Extreme postures tended to change the torque
potential of
some muscles and influence
joint load. Various portions of erector spinae were observed
to have
appreciable potential to
generate torque about all three orthopaedic axes. This
observation
supports the notion held by
some therapists that conditioning of the erector spinae is of
utmost
importance.
On neck muscle activity and
load reduction in sitting postures. An electromyographic and
biomechanical study with applications in ergonomics and
rehabilitation.
Schuldt K
Scand J Rehabil Med Suppl
1988;19:1-49
Department of Physical
Medicine and Rehabilitation Karolinska Institute, Stockholm,
Sweden.
In this study of the
biomechanics and muscular function of the cervical spine,
skilled women
workers simulated standardized
electromechanical assembly work in eight sitting postures.
Normalized electromyography
was used to quantify activity in neck-and-shoulder muscles.
With
the whole spine flexed, muscle
activity in the cervical erector spinae, trapezius and
thoracic
erector spinae muscles was
higher than when the whole spine was straight and vertical.
The
posture with the trunk
slightly inclined backward and neck vertical gave the lowest
activity levels.
Flexed neck compared to
vertical neck gave higher activity in the cervical erector
spinae. Work
with abducted arm gave high
neck muscle activity. Work postures can thus be optimized to
diminish neck muscle load. Two
ergonomic acids were studied during the work cycle. Elbow
support reduced the activity
in the trapezius and thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids muscles
in the
posture with the whole spine
flexed and in the posture with the whole spine vertical. Arm
suspension gave mainly similar
reduction in these postures, and also a reduction in the
cervical
erector spinae. In the
position with the trunk slightly inclined backward, arm
suspension gave a
reduction in the trapezius.
These findings indicate that arm support or arm suspension can
be used
to reduce neck muscle load.
Three methodological studies related to neck muscle load and
normalization were included.
1) Examination of the effect of different isometric maximum
test
contractions on neck muscles
showed that all contractions activated all muscles studied,
including
those on the contralateral
side, to some extent and at various levels. The highest
frequency of
attained maximum levels was:
for neck extension, in cervical erector spinae; for cervical
spinae
lateral flexion, in splenius
and levator scapulae; for arm abduction, in trapezius, and,
for shoulder
elevation and scapular
retraction/elevation, in thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids.
Proximal
resistance gave higher
activity than distal. 2) The relationship between EMG activity
and muscular
moment was studied in women
during submaximal and maximum isometric neck extension. The
relationship found was
non-linear, with greater increase in activity at high moments
in the
posterior neck muscles
studied. The slightly flexed cervical spine position induced a
higher level
of activity in erector spinae
cervicalis than did the neutral position for a given relative
muscular
moment. 3) Muscular activity
was related to cervical spine position during maximum
isometric
neck extension. Peak activity
in the cervical erector spinae was found in the slightly
flexed
lower-cervical spine position.
Intensity and character of
pain and muscular activity levels elicited by maintained
extreme flexion position of the lower-cervical-upper-thoracic
spine.
Harms-Ringdahl K, Ekholm
J Scand J Rehabil Med
1986;18(3):117-26
The aim of this study was to
find out whether maintained extreme flexion position of
the lower-cervical-upper-thoracic spine
in a sitting posture could induce pain, and thus possibly
play a role in work related disorders
with cervico-brachial pain. Ten healthy subjects assessed
pain intensity of
experimentally-induced pain on a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).
The quality and location of the pain
was indicated on a drawing of the body. The load moment
induced by the weight of the
head-and-neck was calculated. The EMG activity levels were
recorded from the splenius, thoracic
erector spinae-rhomboid, and descending part of trapezius
muscles. This posture, which resembles
the posture in some common work, caused pain in all subjects.
The pain was experienced within 15 min,
increased with time, disappeared within 15 min after the
end of provocation, but was again
experienced by nine subjects the same evening or next
morning and lasted up to four days. The
primary location was in the dorsal part of the lower cervical
and upper thoracic spine; three
subjects also reported pain in the arms and one in the head.
The recorded EMG levels were very low,
but they increased somewhat during provocation. It
is suggested that thorough recordings
of work postures should be included in ergonomic analyses
to provide a basis for the avoidance of
such positions which might provoke pain.
Influence of head position on
dorsal neck muscle efficiency.
Mayoux-Benhamou MA, Revel M
Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol
1993 Apr-May;33(3):161-6
Department of rehabilitation,
Hopital Cochin, Paris, France.
The aim of this study was to
assess the influence of head position on dorsal neck
muscle efficiency in the sagittal
plane. Fifteen subjects participated. The EMG versus isometric
extension moment of dorsal neck muscles
was studied in neutral (with subject gazing on a horizontal
plane), cervical flexed, and cervical
extended positions. A vectorial construction was created by
means of photographs to calculate the
extension moment which balances measured pulling force
and gravitational force in isometric
conditions. The maximum extension was highest in neutral
position. The EMG/moment relationship
was non-linear. The ratio between the EMG and the
generated moment differed significantly
in the three positions (p < 0.01) and was lower in neutral
position. These results demonstrate the
influence of head position on dorsal neck muscle
efficiency; muscles appeared most
efficient in neutral position. Muscle length, depending on
head position, is probably the main
influencing factor.
PMID:
8495657, UI: 93265827
Genioglossi muscle activity in
response to changes in anterior/neutral head posture.
Milidonis MK, Kraus SL, Segal
RL, Widmer CG
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop
1993 Jan;103(1):39-44
Orthopaedic Clinical
Specialist, Rehab Services, Akron City Hospital, Ohio.
Clinicians have acknowledged swallowing, tongue activity, and
head posture as interdependent variables that must be
concurrently examined. The purpose of this study was to
evaluate genioglossus activity during
swallowing, rest, and maximal tongue protrusion in two
head positions (HPs) with a noninvasive
recording device. Eight Angle Class I subjects
were evaluated. Repeated measures were
performed in a single session to record surface intraoral
electromyographic (EMG) activity of the genioglossus muscles.
Head position was measured in angular
degrees from photographs. Three variables were measured in
both the neutral-head position (NHP)
and anterior-head position (AHP): (1) duration of genioglossus
EMG during swallowing, (2) genioglossus
EMG with the tongue at rest, and (3) genioglossus EMG
during maximal isometric tongue
protrusion. A Wilcoxin matched-pair signed-rank statistic was
used for EMG analysis, and a paired
sample t test statistic was used for head posture analysis.
The angles measured for NHP and AHP
within each subject were significantly different verifying
two different head positions. Duration
of swallowing was not significantly different between
head positions. Resting genioglossus
EMG and maximal isometric genioglossus EMG were
statistically greater in the AHP. The
data suggest that head positional changes may have an effect
on genioglossus muscle activation
thresholds. However, small differences in resting EMG
activity between head positions
suggests that the clinical significance needs further
investigation.
Influence of muscle
morphometry and moment arms on the moment-generating capacity
of human neck muscles.
Vasavada AN, Li S, Delp SL
Spine 1998 Feb
15;23(4):412-22
Department of Biomedical
Engineering, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: The function of
neck muscles was quantified by incorporating
experimentally measured morphometric
parameters into a three-dimensional biomechanical
model. OBJECTIVE: To analyze how muscle
morphometry and moment arms influence moment-generating
capacity of human neck muscles in physiologic ranges of
motion. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Previous biomechanical
analyses of the head-neck system have used simplified
representations of the musculoskeletal anatomy. The force-
and moment-generating properties of individual neck muscles
have not been reported. METHODS: A computer graphics model
was developed that incorporates detailed neck muscle
morphometric data into a model of cervical musculoskeletal
anatomy and intervertebral kinematics. Moment arms and
force-generating capacity of neck muscles were calculated for
a range of head positions. RESULTS: With the head in the
upright neutral position, the muscles with the
largest moment arms and
moment-generating capacities are sternocleidomastoid in
flexion and lateral bending,
semispinalis capitis and splenius capitis in extension, and
trapezius in axial rotation. The moment
arms of certain neck muscles (e.g., rectus capitis posterior
major in axial rotation) change
considerably in the physiologic range of motion. Most neck
muscles maintain at least 80% of their
peak force-generating capacity throughout the range of motion;
however, the force-generating apacities of muscles with
large moment arms and/or short fascicles (e.g., splenius
capitis) vary substantially with head posture. CONCLUSION:
These results quantify the contributions of individual neck
muscles to moment-generating capacity and demonstrate that
variations in force-generating capacity and moment arm
throughout the range of motion can alter muscle
moment-generating capacities.
[Electromyographic study on
the effects of head position to head and neck muscles].
Omae T, Inoue S, Saito O,
Ishii H, Ishigaki S, Okuda T, Nakamura T, Akanishi M,
Maruyama T
Nippon Hotetsu Shika Gakkai
Zasshi 1989 Apr;33(2):352-8
The purpose of this study is
to reveal the relationship between the head position, and the
neck
and head muscles. At 4 head
positions, the activities of masseter, anterior temporal,
anterior
digastric, sternocleidomastoid
and trapezius muscle of ten normal subjects standing straight
were
investigated
electromyographically with surface electrodes during voluntary
maximal clenching in
centric occlusion. Head
positions were right tilting, left tilting, up-right and
natural head position.
The results obtained were as
follows; 1. During head tilting, the activities of anterior
digastric and sternocleidomastoid muscle
on the tilting side were increased, the activities of masseter
and trapezius muscle on the opposite
side of the tilting side were increased, the activity of the
anterior temporal muscle did not vary
from the activity during up-right head position. 2. During
natural head position, only the
activity of sternocleidomastoid muscle on the natural tilting
side was increased.
Selective electromyography of
dorsal neck muscles in humans.
Mayoux-Benhamou MA, Revel M,
Vallee C
Brain Res 1997
Feb;113(2):353-60
Laboratoire d'Exploration de
l'Appareil Locomoteur et d'Evaluation du Handicap, Universite
Paris V, Hopital Cochin, France.
The patterns of activation of
splenius capitis, semispinalis capitis, transversospinalis,
and levator
scapulae muscles were studied
during various head-neck positions, movements, and
isometric tests in 19 healthy human
subjects. Myoelectric activities were recorded with
intramuscular bipolar wire electrodes.
Cervical computerized tomography of each subject was
performed before the electromyography
session in order to guide electrode insertion. Head motion
was recorded using an electromechanical
device. This report demonstrates that head motion
results from a complex interaction of
active muscular forces, passive ligamentous forces, and
gravity. Splenius capitis has two main
functions, i.e., cervical extension and ipsilateral rotation.
Semi spinalis capitis and the
transversospinalis are mainly extensors, and levator scapulae
acts primarily on the shoulder girdle.
Splenius capitis, semispinalis capitis, and transversospinalis
play a subordinate part in ipsilateral
tilting. In addition, most subjects' semispinalis capitis were
gradually recruited during ipsilateral
rotation. No signal was detected from the transversospinalis
during rotation tests.
Can stress-related shoulder
and neck pain develop independently of muscle activity?
Vasseljen O Jr, Westgaard RH
Pain 1996 Feb;64(2):221-30
Division of Organization and
Work Science, Norwegian Institute of Technology, University
of Trondheim, Norway.
A case-control designed was
used to investigate associations and interactions between
muscle activity measured by surface
electromyography (EMG) in the upper trapezius muscle
and subjectively reported risk factors
in workers with and without shoulder and neck pain. EMG data
were collected both in the workplace
(indicating vocational muscle activity) and in a
laboratory setting (indicating
non-specific muscle activity). Women in manual (15 pairs) and
office (24 pairs) work were included.
The pairs were matched on age, gender and on current and
historical work load, such as working
hours, type and length of employment. Previous reports of this
study have indicated that shoulder and
neck myalgia was associated with increased muscle activity for
the manual workers, and with
psychological and psychosocial factors for the office workers.
These risk factors were in the present
report used as the basis for studying associations and
interactions between muscle activity
(1), psychological and psychosocial factors (2), and shoulder
and neck pain (3). Subjectively
reported or perceived general tension, a stress symptom
presumed related to psychosocial and
psychological factors, was previously found to be the
strongest and only variable separating
cases and controls in both work groups. In this paper, no
relationship was found between
perceived general tension and EMG variables for the office
workers. For the manual workers a
strong interaction was found; perceived general tension
correlated positively with EMG
variables for the controls, and negatively with EMG variables
for the cases. It is hypothesised that
the feeling of general tension represents a physiological
activation response that may or may not
include muscle fibre activation. This implies that pain
provoked by psychosocial stress factors
may not be mediated through increased muscle activity.
J Spinal Disord 2000
Feb;13(1):26-30
Surgical correction of lumbar
kyphotic deformity: posterior reduction "eggshell" osteotomy.
Danisa OA, Turner D,
Richardson WJ
J Neurosurg 2000 Jan;92(1
Suppl):50-6
Department of Surgery, Duke
University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina, USA.
OBJECT: Progressive kyphotic
deformity of the lumbar or thoracolumbar spine may lead to
back pain, cosmetic deformity,
and risk of neurological compromise. The authors describe a
series of patients in whom
they performed a single-stage, posterior reduction
("eggshell")
osteotomy procedure to improve
sagittal contour by creating lordosis within a single
vertebral
body. METHODS: From 1995 to
1997 the authors performed 12 osteotomy procedures in 11
patients with thoracolumbar or
lumbar kyphosis. Seven patients presented with iatrogenic
deformity, three with
deformity secondary to traumatic injury, and one patient
with akylosing spondylitis. Their mean age at time of
surgery was 46.6 years (range 23-78 years). All patients
suffered from back pain and
were unable to stand upright, but in only one patient
were neurological findings
demonstrated. The mean preoperative deformity was -26 degrees
(range -90 to 0 degrees). At 6-month
follow-up examination the mean sagittal contour measured
17.5 degrees (range - 17 to 44
degrees), indicating that the mean surgical correction was
40.1 degrees (range 25 to 58 degrees).
All patients reported decreased back pain at follow up, and
none required narcotic analgesic
medication. Complications included a dense paresis that
developed immediately postoperatively
in a patient who was found to have residual dural
compression, which was corrected by
emergency decompressive surgery. One elderly patient suffered
a perioperative cerebrovascular
accident, and three patients suffered neurapraxia with
transient muscle weakness of the
quadriceps. There was one case of a dural tear. There were no
deaths, and prolonged intensive care
stays were not required. CONCLUSIONS: Single-level
posterior reduction osteotomy provides
excellent sagittal correction of kyphotic deformity in the
lumbar region, with a risk of cauda
equina and root and plexus compromise due to the extensive
neural exposure
Cervical laminectomy and
dentate ligament section for cervical spondylotic myelopathy.
Benzel EC, Lancon J, Kesterson
L, Hadden T
J Spinal Disord 1991
Sep;4(3):286-95
Division of Neurosurgery,
University of New Mexico School of Medicine, Albuquerque
87131.
Seventy-five patients who
underwent surgical treatment for cervical spondylotic
myelopathy were
evaluated with respect to the
operative procedure performed and their outcome. Forty
patients underwent a laminectomy plus
dentate ligament section (DLS), 18 underwent laminectomy
alone, and 17 underwent an anterior
cervical decompression and fusion (ACDF). The patients
were evaluated postoperatively for both
stability and for neurologic outcome using a modification of
the Japanese Orthopaedic Association
Assessment Scale. Functional improvement occurred in
all but one patient in the laminectomy
plus DLS group. The average improvement was 3.1 +/-
1.5 points in this group; whereas the
average improvement in the laminectomy and the ACDF
groups was 2.7 +/- 2.0 and 3.0 +/- 2.0
points respectively. All of the patients who
improved substantially (greater than or
equal to 6 points) in the laminectomy plus DLS and the
laminectomy alone groups had normal
cervical spine contours (lordosis). The remainder had either a
normal lordosis or no curve (no
kyphosis or lordosis). All patients in the ACDF group had
either a straight spine or a cervical
kyphosis. These factors implicate spine curvature, in addition
to choice of operation, as factors
which are important in outcome determination. No problems
with instability occurred in either the
laminectomy or the laminectomy plus DLS group. Two
patients incurred problems with
stability in the ACDF group. Both required reoperation. In
addition, four patients in this group
who initially improved, subsequently deteriorated. Six
patients in the laminectomy plus DLS
group had a several day febrile episode related to an aseptic
meningitis process. Laminectomy plus
DLS is a safe and efficacious alternative to laminectomy for
the treatment of cervical spondylotic
myelopathy. The data presented here suggests that myelopathic
patients with a cervical kyphosis are best treated with an
ACDF and that patients with a normal
cervical lordosis are best treated with a posterior approach.
Although some selected patients may
benefit from DLS, no criteria are available which
differentiate this small subset of patients.
##18 Degenerative symptomatic
lumbar scoliosis.
Pritchett JW, Bortel DT
Spine 1993 May;18(6):700-3
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, University of Washington.
Scoliosis with progressive
deformity can develop late in life. The authors studied 200
patients older than age 50 years with
back pain and recent onset of scoliosis. Seventy-one percent
of patients were women, and no patient
had undergone spinal surgery. The curves involved the
area from T12 to L5 with the apex at L2
or L3 and did not exceed 60 degrees. Degenerative
facet joint and disc disease always
were present, and the curves were associated with a loss of
lumbar lordosis. Forty-five patients
with severe pain and neurologic deficits were studied
using myelography. Indention of the column
of contrast medium was seen at several levels but
was most severe at the apex of the
curve. It was least severe at the lumbosacral joint. The
curves progressed an average of 3
degrees per year over a 5-year period in 73% of patients.
Grade 3 apical rotation, a Cobb angle
of 30 or more, lateral vertebral translation of 6 mm or more,
and the prominence of L5 in relation to
the intercrest line were important factors in predicting
curve progression.
Cervical spondylotic
myelopathy: a review of surgical indications and decision
making.
Law MD Jr, Bernhardt M, White
AA 3d
Yale J Biol Med 1993
May-Jun;66(3):165-77
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Beth Israel Hospital/Harvard Medical School,
Boston, Massachusetts 02215.
Cervical spondylotic
myelopathy (CSM) is frequently underdiagnosed and undertreated.
The key
to the initial diagnosis is a
careful neurologic examination. The physical findings may be
subtle,
thus a high index of suspicion
is helpful. Poor prognostic indicators and, therefore,
absolute
indications for surgery are:
1. Progression of signs and symptoms. 2. Presence of
myelopathy for
six months or longer. 3.
Compression ratio approaching 0.4 or transverse area of the
spinal cord
of 40 square millimeters or
less. Improvement is unusual with nonoperative treatment and
almost
all patients progressively
worsen. Surgical intervention is the most predictable way to
prevent
neurologic deterioration. The
recommended decompression is anterior when there is anterior
compression at one or two
levels and no significant developmental narrowing of the
canal. For
compression at more than two
levels, developmental narrowing of the canal, posterior
compression, and ossification
of the posterior longitudinal ligament, we recommend posterior
decompression. In order for
posterior decompression to be effective there must be lordosis
of
the cervical spine. If
kyphosis is present, anterior decompression is needed.
Kyphosis associated
with a developmentally narrow
canal or posterior compression may require combined anterior
and posterior approaches.
Fusion is required for instability.
Surgical treatment of
adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: the basics and the
controversies.
Bridwell KH
Spine 1994 May
1;19(9):1095-100
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St.
Louis, Missouri.
Decisions about when to
operate should be based on more than just an arbitrary
Cobb measurement. The patient's skeletal
maturity, balance, and other parameters of curve size
also should be considered. Although it
is desirable to fuse as few segments as possible, there is
no benefit to fusing short if the top
and bottom of the fusion is not neutral and stable. Especially
for lumbar fusions, the last
instrumented vertebra must be stable, neutral, and horizontal
to the sacrum postoperatively. Many
thoracic/lumbar curve patterns are Type II (false double
major) and not double major curves.
They often can be treated with selective thoracic fusion.
However, many variables are involved,
and the potential for decompensation should be discussed with
the patient and the patient's family so
they know that it may be necessary to later add the
lumbar curve. The rod rotation maneuver
and anterior segmental spinal instrumentation often may
save fusion levels over what may have
been needed with Harrington instrumentation. However,
there are many variables here as well.
Surgeons should be particularly concerned with maintaining
and re-creating enough segmental
lordosis for the patient so the spine can withstand the
inevitable aging process.
[Radiological studies of the
cervical spine after laminoplasty by longitudinal splitting of
the spinous process].
Shimizu Y
Nippon Ika Daigaku Zasshi 1995
Aug;62(4):369-76
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Nippon Medical School Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
This study involved a clinical
evaluation and radiological follow-up of patients who
underwent
laminoplasty by longitudinal
splitting of the spinous process for compressive myelopathy.
The
subjects were 47 patients with
myelopathy caused by cervical spondylosis or ossification of
the
posterior longitudinal
ligament in the cervical spine. The average age at the time of
surgery was
61, and the average follow-up
period was 3 years. Overall results: the preoperative score,
by the
Japanese Orthopaedic
Association scoring system, was 9.8, and the postoperative
score was
13.9; the average recovery
rate was 54.3%. Lateral roentgenograms showed a decreased
lordosis in the cervical
curvature in 50% of the patients after laminoplasty,
especially in those
patients where stripping of
the attachments of the semispinalis cervices to the spinous
process of
C2 occurred. The recovery
rate was good in patients with postoperative lordotic or
straightened
necks (61.1% and 55.0%,
respectively), but it was poor in those with kyphotic or
S-shaped
necks (average: 36.1%).
The postoperative range of motion of the cervical spine had
decreased
to 43% of the preoperative
range.
##19 Realignment of
postoperative cervical kyphosis in children by vertebral
remodeling.
Toyama Y, Matsumoto M, Chiba
K, Asazuma T, Suzuki N, Fujimura Y, Hirabayashi K
Spine 1994 Nov
15;19(22):2565-70
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
STUDY DESIGN. This study
analyzed radiographically change in the sagittal curvature of
the
cervical spine after
atlantoaxial (C1-C2) posterior fusion in children. OBJECTIVES.
This study
clarified the process of
spinal remodeling after postoperative cervical deformation in
children.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.
Postoperative spinal deformations in children are
observed frequently. However,
there have been only a few reports on postoperative changes in
the sagittal curvature of the
cervical spine and spinal remodeling after those changes.
METHODS. Between 1979 and
1991, there was a total of 12 children who underwent C1-C2
posterior fusions. The average
age at the time of surgery was 9.8 years. The alignment of the
cervical spine was classified
into four groups (lordosis, straight, kyphosis, and swan-neck
deformity). Radiographic
findings suggestive of the remodeling were as follows: 1) new
bone
formation on the anterior
vertebral cortex, and 2) increase in body/canal ratio (BCR).
The
follow-up period averaged 6.2
years. RESULTS. Postoperative cervical malalignment (kyphosis
or swan-neck deformity)
occurred in four patients. In all four patients, new bone
formation and
increase in BCR at the apex of
kyphosis were observed. Therefore, there was gradual
improvement of the
malalignment by vertebral remodeling. This phenomenon was not
observed in
eight patients with normal
alignment. CONCLUSION. Realignment of postoperative
cervical
kyphosis by vertebral
remodeling was observed in children. The results of this study
suggested
that remodeling occurred even
in the spine, which was similar to the remodeling in long
bones.
Comparison of lumbar sagittal
alignment produced by different operative positions.
Stephens GC, Yoo JU, Wilbur G
Spine 1996 Aug
1;21(15):1802-6; discussion 1807
Division of Orthopaedics,
University of Kentucky, Lexington, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: This study is a
prospective evaluation of the effects of commonly used spinal
tables on lumbar sagittal
alignment. OBJECTIVES: The objective was to determine the
differences, if any, in lumbar
sagittal alignment produced by different positions on
routinely used
spinal operating tables.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Earlier studies have
documented the advantages of
the knee-chest position in lumbar decompressive procedures.
When simultaneous fusion is
performed and augmented with internal fixation, intraoperative
position is the critical
determinant of sagittal plane balance. Other investigators
have documented
an association between the
knee-chest position and decreased lumbar lordosis. METHODS:
Ten
asymptomatic volunteers
underwent a series of four lateral lumbar radiographs, as
follows:
standing, prone on the Jackson
(Orthopaedic Systems, Inc., Hayword, CA) spinal table, and
prone on the Andrews
(Orthopaedic Systems, Inc.) table with the hips flexed 60
degrees and 90
degrees, respectively.
Intervertebral body angle measurements were obtained from L1
to S1.
Lordosis values were compared
and analyzed for each of the positions. Standing lordosis was
assumed to be physiologic.
RESULTS: Physiologic lordosis values were produced only on the
Jackson operative table. Both
positions on the Andrews table resulted in a statistically
significant
decrease in lumbar lordosis.
Decreasing hip flexion on the Andrews table from 90 degrees to
60
degrees produced a
statistically significant increase in lumbar lordosis.
However, this change did
not reproduce physiologic
values. CONCLUSION: When instrumentation is used to augment
lumbar fusions, positions
incorporating hip flexion should be avoided to ensure
maintenance of
sagittal plane balance.
##20 Failure of magnetic
resonance imaging to reveal the cause of a progressive
cervical myelopathy related to postoperative spinal deformity:
a case report.
Stein J
Am J Phys Med Rehabil 1997
Jan-Feb;76(1):73-5
Spaulding Rehabilitation
Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02114, USA.
Imaging studies have achieved
a high degree of diagnostic accuracy for many disorders of the
spinal cord but have
significant limitations. We report on the case of a 49-yr-old
man who
developed neck pain and arm
numbness. He was found to have extensive cervical spondylosis,
with spinal cord impingement
at C3-4 and cervical radiculopathy. He underwent a C3-7
laminectomy, with transient
improvement in his symptoms. During the ensuing year, he
developed
increased weakness of the
upper limbs, evidence of cervical myelopathy, and a severely
flexed
posture of the cervical spine.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed cervical spinal cord
atrophy but no evidence of
extrinsic spinal cord compression. Cervical flexion and
extension films
revealed reversal of the
normal cervical lordosis without segmental instability.
Despite the
absence of confirmatory
radiologic studies, the patient was felt to have clinical
evidence of
intermittent compression of
his cervical spinal cord attributable to excessive cervical
kyphosis,
was provided with a cervical
collar, and subsequently underwent surgical stabilization. His
cervical myelopathy showed
marked improvement with these treatments. We conclude that
intermittent compression of
the spinal cord, occurring in the erect position, was not
apparent on
the MRI films obtained in the
supine position. Flexion and extension films, obtained in the
upright
position, documented his
abnormal cervical anatomy but did not reveal substantial
segmental
instability. Spinal deformity
without segmental instability may cause cervical myelopathy
after
multilevel cervical
laminectomies without evidence of extrinsic compression on
MRI.
The possibility of creating
lordosis and correcting scoliosis simultaneously after
partial disc removal. Balance lines of lumbar motion segments.
Ogon M, Haid C, Krismer M,
Jesenko R, Wimmer C
Spine 1996 Nov
1;21(21):2458-62
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, University of Innsbruck, Austria.
STUDY DESIGN: The feasibility
of correcting scoliosis and creating lordosis simultaneously
in
the thoracolumbar and lumbar
spine by anterior instrumentation was investigated by in vitro
testing. OBJECTIVES: To
evaluate the vertebral zones in which a compressive load
applied in a
motion segment creates side
bending and lordosis in intact motion segments and after
partial disc
removal. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND
DATA: Most investigators have observed a
kyphogenic effect of anterior
scoliosis instrumentation and recommended dorsal placement of
screws and the use of wedge
grafts, although wedge grafts were not used routinely by all
surgeons. METHODS: Zones of
lordosization and side bending were determined by evaluation
of balance lines between
extension-flexion and side bending, respectively, by axial
loading on
ligamentous human motion
segments with intact discs and after partial disc removal.
RESULTS:In
lumbar motion segments with
intact discs, it is possible to achieve ipsilateral side
bending and
lordosization by anterior
instrumentation. After partial disc removal, the balance line
between
extension and flexion runs
through the ipsilateral pedicle, and, therefore, a compressive
load
between the vertebral bodies
always creates kyphosis. CONCLUSIONS: After partial disc
removal, it is not possible to
create lordosis and correction of scoliosis simultaneously by
ipsilateral anterior
instrumentation without the use of intervertebral wedge
grafts.
PMID:
8923631, UI: 97082395
###########
Cervical curvature after
laminoplasty for spondylotic myelopathy--involvement of
yellow ligament, semispinalis cervicis muscle, and nuchal
ligament.
Sasai K, Saito T, Akagi S,
Kato I, Ogawa R
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Kansai Medical University, Osaka, Japan.
To assess the consequences of
cervical laminoplasty on postoperative lordosis, a
retrospective
radiographic analysis of 31
patients undergoing laminoplasty for spondylotic myelopathy
was
completed. Special attention
was paid to lordotic changes occurring at each level over more
than
2 years. Preoperative lordosis
remained unchanged with the patients wearing a cervical
orthosis 1
week postoperatively. However
the lordosis subsequently demonstrated a significant decrease
in
87% of patients over an
average of 3.1 years. Lordotic alignment at C2-C3 and C6-C7
before
surgery significantly
decreased in 81% and 58% of patients 1 week postoperatively,
and 84%
and 81% at last follow up,
respectively, while lordotic alignment at other levels pre-
and
postoperatively did not
significantly change. Loss of lordotic alignment was largely
attributed to
detachment of semispinalis
cervicis muscle on C2 and nuchal ligament on C6/C7 with a
posterior
approach and/or section of
yellow ligament at C2-C3.
Spasm or joint dysfunction…you
be the judge….
The straight cervical spine:
does it indicate muscle spasm?
Helliwell PS, Evans PF, Wright
V
J Bone Joint Surg Br 1994
Jan;76(1):103-6
Huddersfield Royal Infirmary,
Leeds, England.
The loss of cervical lordosis
in radiographs of patients presenting with neck pain is
sometimes
ascribed to muscle spasm. We
performed a cross-sectional study of the prevalence of
'straight'
cervical spines in three
populations: 83 patients presenting to an accident department
with acute
neck pain, 83 referred to a
radiology department with chronic neck problems, and 80
radiographs from a normal
population survey carried out in 1958. Curvature was assessed
on
lateral radiographs both
subjectively and by measurement. The prevalence of 'straight'
cervical
spines was 19% in the acute
cases and 26% in the chronic cases. The 95% confidence
interval
for the difference was -6.4%
to +19.3%. In the normal population 42% showed a straight
spine,
but a further third of these
films had been taken in a position of cervical kyphosis; this
probably
reflects a difference in
positioning technique. Women were more likely than men to have
a straight
cervical spine, with an odds
ratio of 2.81 (95% CI 1.23 to 6.44).>>>>>> Our results fail to
support the
hypothesis that loss of
cervical lordosis reflects muscle spasm caused by pain in the
neck.
Saggital changes from
radiographic positioning? Or does the saggital configuration
remain consistent?
You be the judge….
Effect of patient position on
the sagittal-plane profile of the thoracolumbar spine.
Wood KB, Kos P, Schendel M,
Persson K
J Spinal Disord 1996
Apr;9(2):165-9
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455, USA.
Although the normal sagittal
profile of the thoracolumbar spine has been described, this
has been
obtained primarily by using
young individuals standing. >>>>>>We sought to describe the
sagittal profile
of the thoracolumbar spine in
an older population in the supine cross-table lateral position
compared with that standing.
We enrolled 50 volunteers with no history of back pain or
spine
deformity and 50 matched
subjects with mechanical back pain (LBP) only. Lateral
radiographs
of the thoracolumbar spine
(T10-S1) in both standing and cross-table supine positions
were
obtained. Lordosis from L1
to S1, kyphosis from T10 to L1, >>>>> and the changes seen
moving from
the supine position to
standing were calculated. >>>>>There were few differences
comparing the two
groups in either the standing
or cross-table supine position, or when changing positions.
Within
each group, however, there
were small, but significant, differences in the midlumbar and
thoracolumbar spine when
comparing supine versus standing. Both asymptomatic
individuals and
those with a history of LBP
demonstrated similar small but statistically significant
increases in
lumbar lordosis and
thoracolumbar kyphosis when standing versus supine. The
clinical
significance of these
findings remains to be determined.
Can radiographic mensuration
be used as an outcome? You be the judge…..
Apophysial joint degeneration,
disc degeneration, and sagittal curve of the cervical spine.
Can they be measured reliably on radiographs?
Cote P, Cassidy JD, Yong-Hing
K, Sibley J, Loewy J
Spine 1997 Apr
15;22(8):859-64
Division of Orthopaedics,
University of Saskatchewan, Canada.
STUDY DESIGN: Interexaminer
reliability study. OBJECTIVES: To determine the reliability of
grading apophysial joint and
disc degenerative changes and the reliability of measuring
sagittal
curves on lateral cervical
spine radiographs. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Several
authors have proposed that the
presented of degenerative changes and the absence of lordosis
in
the cervical spine are
indicators of poor recovery from neck injuries caused by motor
vehicle
collisions. The validity of
those conclusions is questionable because the reliability of
the methods
used in their studies to
measure the presence of degenerative changes and the absence
of lordosis
has not been determined.
METHODS: Kellgren's classification system for apophysial joint
and
disc degeneration, as well as
the pattern and magnitude of the sagittal curve on 30 lateral
cervical
spine radiographs were
assessed independently by three examiners. RESULTS: Moderate
reliability was demonstrated
for classifying apophysial joint degeneration with an
intraclass
correlation coefficient of
0.45 (95% confidence interval, 0.09-0.71). Classifying
degenerative
disc disease had substantial
reliability, with an intraclass correlation coefficient of
0.71 (95%
confidence interval,
0.23-0.88). Measuring the magnitude of the sagittal curve from
C2 to C7
had excellent interexaminer
agreement, with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.96
(95%
confidence interval,
0.88-0.98) and an interexaminer error of 8.3 degrees.>>>>
CONCLUSIONS:
The classification system for
degenerative disc disease proposed by Kellgren et al and the
method of measurement of
sagittal curves from C2 to C7 demonstrated an acceptable level
of
reliability and can be used in
outcomes research.
A]Do manipulations and
specific adjustive procedures produce different outcomes in
spinal configuration?
You be the judge…..
B] Does the spine change all
by itself???
An evaluation of the effect of
chiropractic manipulative therapy on hypolordosis of the
cervical spine.
Leach RA
J Manipulative Physiol Ther
1983 Mar;6(1):17-23
Cervical curve depth (CCD) was
radiographically evaluated in 35 patients who presented with
cervical hypolordosis or
kyphosis (CH/K). Of these, one group of 20 patients received
chiropractic manipulative
therapy (CMT) for the purpose of correcting the disorder. A
second
group of nine patients
received both CMT and an orthopedic cervical pillow for in
home
correction of the CH/K. A
control group of six patients received CMT which was not
intended
to correct the CH/K. The
purpose of the study was to determine the efficacy of CMT in
the
correction of CH/K.
>>>>>Analysis of the data indicated that CMT is significantly
effective in the
treatment of CH/K. There was a
mean improvement of 4.55 degrees (p less than 0.01) in the
group receiving only CMT, as
assessed by CCD radiographic analysis. There was also
significant
improvement of 2.22 degrees (p
less than 0.05) in the group receiving both CMT and orthopedic
cervical pillow therapy. The
findings lend support to fundamental chiropractic tenets such
as that
spinal manipulation is
beneficial in correcting biomechanical disorders of the spine.
Specifically,
the study documents the role
of chiropractic care in the correction of CH/K as may result
from
postural, musculoligamentous,
or traumatic etiology such as the so-called "whiplash" injury.
Want a human experimental
study, lets thank our friends the surgeons….. (we couldn’t ask
for a better study if we did it ourselves)
Axial symptoms and cervical
alignments after cervical anterior spinal fusion for patients
with cervical myelopathy.
Kawakami M, Tamaki T, Yoshida
M, Hayashi N, Ando M, Yamada H
J Spinal Disord 1999
Feb;12(1):50-6
Department of Orthopedic
Surgery, Wakayama Medical College, Wakayama City, Japan.
This retrospective clinical
study was designed to examine the relation between cervical
alignment
and axial symptoms developing
after cervical anterior spinal fusion. Sixty patients with
myelopathy treated with
cervical anterior spinal fusion were reviewed. For
radiographic
evaluation, lordosis,
enlargement of the fused segments and neural foramen,
radiographic union,
and degeneration of adjacent
segment were reviewed before or after surgery or both.
Twenty-three patients had
axial symptoms. >>>>Only local kyphosis and narrowing of the
neural
foramen at the fused segment
were recognized more often in patients with axial symptoms
than in
those without such symptoms.
>>>>> No less than 2 mm and < or = 5 mm in enlargement of the
anterior
disc space immediately after
surgery resulted in maintenance of cervical lordosis. These
findings
suggest that > or = 2 mm and <
or = 5 mm in enlargement of anterior vertebral body height
during operation results in
prevention of axial symptoms.
Restoring lordois, is it
important? What do the surgeons say????
The role of lordosis.
Beckers L, Bekaert J
Acta Orthop Belg 1991;57
Suppl 1:198-202
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Imeldaziekenhuis, Bonheiden, Belgium.
A majority of degenerative
changes in the vertebral discs, the facet joints or even the
interspinous
ligaments, as in Baastrup's
disease, are probably caused by pressure damage. Among the
various
causes of overloading,
hyperlordosis--alone or in combination with other adjuvant
causes--is
presumably the most important
one. Its detrimental influence is most noticeable in some
peculiar
situations, where lordosis is
the common denominator of malformations of different origins,
as, for
instance, dorsal and
dorsolumbar kyphosis, L4-5 facetarthrosis with L5-S1
spondylolisthesis,
and posterior or
posterolateral distraction arthrodesis. >>>>>It is now
recognized that arthrodesis in the
lumbar spine should be done in
normal lordosis or even slight hyperlordosis in order to
respect,
or even to improve the stress
distribution in the mobile segments. After lumbosacral
arthrodesis,
as well as in common
"everyday" low back pain problems, protection of the disks and
facet joints
from prolonged continuous
loading is essential for the prevention of continuing
degeneration.
Cervical curvature in acute
whiplash injuries: prospective comparative study with
asymptomatic subjects.
Matsumoto M, Fujimura Y,
Suzuki N, Toyama Y, Shiga H
Injury 1998 Dec;29(10):775-8
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
The cervical curvature of 488
patients with acute whiplash injury was prospectively studied
by
comparison with 495
asymptomatic healthy volunteers. Plain radiography of the
cervical spine in
the neutral position was
evaluated qualitatively. No significant difference was noted
in frequencies
of non-lordotic cervical
curvature and local angular kyphosis between acute whiplash
injury
patients and asymptomatic
subjects. No significant association was apparent between
clinical
symptoms and cervical
curvature. These results suggest that non-lordotic cervical
curvature and
angular kyphosis in acute
whiplash injury patients constitute normal variants rather
than
pathological findings.
Neuroradiology 1997
Jan;39(1):35-40
MRI of
car occupants with whiplash injury.
Voyvodic F, Dolinis J, Moore VM, Ryan GA, Slavotinek JP,
Whyte AM, Hoile RD,
Taylor
GW
National Injury Surveillance Unit, Bedford Park, South
Australia.
Our purpose was to document
and investigate the prognostic significance of features seen
on
MRI of patients with whiplash
injury following relatively minor road traffic crashes. MRI
was
obtained shortly and at 6
months after the crash using a 0.5 T imager. The images were
assessed
independently by two
radiologists for evidence of fracture or other injury; loss of
lordosis and
spondylosis were also
recorded. Clinical examinations were used to assess the status
of patients
initially and at 6 months. The
results of the independent MRI and clinical investigations
were then
examined for association using
statistical tests. Initial MRI was performed on 29 patients,
of
whom 19 had repeat studies at
6 months; 48 examinations were thus examined. Apart from
spondylosis and loss of
lordosis, only one abnormality was detected: an intramedullary
lesion
consistent with a small cyst
or syrinx. There were no statistically significant
associations between
the outcome of injury and
spondylosis or loss of lordosis. No significant changes were
found
when comparing the initial
and follow-up MRI. It appears that MRI of patients with
relatively less
severe whiplash symptoms
reveals a low frequency of abnormalities, apart from
spondylosis and
loss of lordosis, which
have little short-term prognostic value. Routine investigation
of such
patients with MRI is not
justified in view of the infrequency of abnormalities
detected, the lack of
prognostic value and the
high cost of the procedure.
Skeletal Radiol 1995
May;24(4):263-6
Hyperextension strain or "whiplash" injuries to the cervical
spine.
Griffiths HJ, Olson PN, Everson LI, Winemiller M
Department of Radiology,
University of Minnesota Hospital and Clinical, Minneapolis
55455, USA.
PURPOSE. To define
"whiplash" radiologically. MATERIAL AND METHODS. A full
cervical
spine radiographic series
(including flexion and extension views) was reviewed in 40
patients with
clinically proven "whiplash"
injuries and compared to the radiographs in 105 normal
controls. The
level and degree of kinking or
kyphosis, subluxation, and the difference in the amount of
fanning
between spinous processes on
flexion and extension films were measured in each patient.
RESULTS. Localized kinking
greater than 10 degrees and over 12 mm of fanning, often
occurring at the level below
the kinking or kyphosis, occurred mainly in the group of
whiplash
patients (sensitivity 81%,
specificity 76%, accuracy 80%). CONCLUSIONS. Localized kinking
greater than 10 degrees and
fanning greater than 12 mm are useful measurements by which to
separate patients with true
whiplash injuries from those with minor ligamentous tears.
Flexion and
extension views are
essential to help define whiplash and other ligamentous
injuries of the cervical
spine.
Ability to reproduce head
position after whiplash injury.
Loudon JK, Ruhl M, Field E
Spine 1997 Apr 15;22(8):865-8
Department of Physical
Therapy Education, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas
City,
USA.
STUDY DESIGN: A two-group
design with repeated measures. OBJECTIVES: To determine if
there is loss of the ability
to reproduce target position of the cervical spine individuals
who have
sustained a whiplash injury.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The ability to sense
position is a prerequisite
for functional movement. Injury may have a deleterious effect
on this
ability, resulting in
inaccurate positioning of the head and neck with respect to
the body
coordinates and to the
environment. METHODS: Eleven subjects with history of whiplash
injury
(age, 42 +/- 8.7 years) and
11 age-matched asymptomatic subjects (age, 43 +/- 3.1 years)
participated in the study.
Effects of whiplash injury on the ability to replicate a
target position of
the head were assessed.
Maximum rotation of the neck and ability to reproduce the
target angle
were measured using a
standard cervical range-of-motion device. Subjects' perception
of
"neutral" position was also
assessed. RESULTS: Analysis of variance indicated the whiplash
subjects were less accurate
in reproducing the target angle than were control subjects.
These
whiplash subjects tended to
overshoot the target. In addition, the subjects in the
whiplash group
were often inaccurate in
their assessment of neutral position. CONCLUSIONS: Subjects
who
have experienced a whiplash
injury demonstrate a deficit in their ability to reproduce a
target
position of the neck. These
data are consistent with the hypothesis that these subjects
possess an
inaccurate perception of
head position secondary to their injury. This study has
implications for
the rehabilitation of
individuals with whiplash injury.
The influence of lordosis on
axial trunk torque and trunk muscle myoelectric activity.
McGill SM
Spine 1992 Oct;17(10):1187-93
Department of Kinesiology, University of Waterloo, Ontario,
Canada.
Force contributions from the
facet complex and posterior ligaments during the generation of
axial
torque are a function of
lordosis, and it has been speculated that these forces
together with
muscular contributions play
a role in axial trunk twisting. This study investigated the
electromyographic activity of
the trunk musculature and torque-generating capacity of the
lumbar
spine under the conditions of
normal lordosis, hyperlordosis, and hypolordosis. Eleven male
subjects volunteered for
this study. The subjects performed isometric twisting efforts
and
maximum dynamic twisting
efforts at 30 degrees/sec. The myoelectric activity levels
(normalized
to maximal amplitude obtained
from nontwist activities) were quite low despite maximal
efforts to
generate axial torque (for
example: approximately 60% maximum voluntary contraction for
latissimus dorsi and even
lower for the abdominals). Furthermore, changes in lordosis
did not
produce any consistent
changes in muscle activity, although a hyperlordotic spine
produced
significantly smaller axial
torques, and a hypolordotic spine smaller still. Larger
torques were
measured during all three
conditions of lordosis, as the subjects rotated toward an
untwisted
position, and lower torques
as the subjects rotated away. The opposite trend was observed,
however, in myoelectric
activity of the agonistic side of latissimus dorsi, the
thoracic level of
erector spine, and the
lumbar level of erector spinae, i.e., larger amplitudes were
observed as the
trunk was twisted away from
the untwisted position. These data suggest that tissues other
than
muscle (i.e., passive
tissue) contribute significantly to axial torque production
and that the flexed
and twisted spine is less
able to resist applied axial torques, possibly increasing the
risk of
torsional injury.
Segmental analysis of the
sagittal plane alignment of the normal thoracic and lumbar
spines and thoracolumbar junction.
Bernhardt M, Bridwell KH
Spine 1989 Jul;14(7):717-21
Department of Surgery, University of Kansas School of
Medicine, Wichita.
Recent advances in spinal
instrumentation have brought about a new emphasis on the
three-dimensional spinal
deformity of scoliosis and especially on the restoration of
normal sagittal
plane contours. Normal
alignment in the coronal and transverse planes is easily
defined; however,
normal sagittal plane
alignment is not so simple. This retrospective study was
undertaken to
increase the understanding of
the normal alignment of the spine in the sagittal plane, with
a special
emphasis on the
thoracolumbar junction. Measurements were made from the
lateral radiographs
of 102 subjects with
clinically and radiographically normal spines. Cobb
measurements of the
thoracic kyphosis (T3-T12),
the thoracolumbar junction (T10-T12 and T12-L2), and the
lumbar
lordosis (L1-L5) were
determined. The spices of the thoracic kyphosis and lumbar
lordosis also
were determined. Using a
computerized digitalizing table, the segmental angulation was
determined at each level from
T1-2 to L5-S1. In conclusion, there is a wide range of normal
sagittal alignment of the
thoracic and lumbar spines. When using composite measurements
of the
combined frontal and sagittal
plane deformity of scoliosis, this wide range of sagittal
variance
should be taken into
consideration. Using norms established here for segmental
alignment, areas
of hypokyphosis and
hypolordosis commonly seen in scoliosis can be more
objectively evaluated.
The thoracolumbar junction is
for all practical purposes straight; lumbar lordosis usually
starts at
L1-2 and gradually
increases at each level caudally to the sacrum.
Erector spinae lever arm
length variations with changes in spinal curvature.
Tveit P, Daggfeldt K, Hetland
S, Thorstensson A
Spine 1994 Jan
15;19(2):199-204
Department of Physiology III,
Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Magnetic resonance imaging was
used to study the effect of different curvatures in the lumbar
spine on lever arm lengths of
the erector spinae musculature. Eleven subjects were
instructed to
simulate static lifts while
lying supine in a magnetic resonance camera with the lumbar
spine either
in kyphosis or lordosis. A
sagittal image of the spine was obtained to analyze the
lumbosacral
angle and to guide the imaging
of transverse sections through each disc (L1/L2 to L5/S1).
Images
were analyzed for lever arm
lengths of the erector spinae muscle (ES) and the erector
spinae
aponeurosis (ESA), the latter
functioning as a tendon for superiorly positioned ES muscle
portions. The lumbosacral
angle (between superior surfaces of S1 and L4) averaged 44
degrees
in the lordosed, 26 degrees in
the kyphosed and 41 degrees in a neutral supine position. In
lordosis, the lever arm
lengths were significantly longer than in kyphosis for all
levels, averaging
60-63 mm (ES) and 82-86 mm
(ESA). The corresponding values for kyphosis were 49-57 mm
(ES) and 67-77 mm (ESA),
respectively. Thus, there was a considerable effect (10-24%)
of
lumbar curvature on lever arm
lengths for the back extensor muscles. The change in leverage
will
affect the need for extensor
muscle force and thus the magnitude of compression in the
lumbar
spine in loading situations
such as lifting.
Commonly adopted postures
and their effect on the lumbar spine.
Dolan P, Adams MA, Hutton WC
Spine 1988 Feb;13(2):197-201
Polytechnic of Central
London, England.
The activity of the erector
spinae muscles and the changes in lumbar curvature were
measured in
11 subjects in a range of
commonly adopted postures to see if there were any consistent
trends.
Surface electrodes were used
to measure back muscle activity and lumbar curvature was
measured using electronic
inclinometers. The results showed that many commonly adopted
postures reduced the lumbar
lordosis when compared with erect standing or sitting, even at
the
expense of increasing the
back muscle activity.
The effects of flexion on
the geometry and actions of the lumbar erector spinae.
Macintosh JE, Bogduk N, Pearcy
MJ
Spine 1993 Jun 1;18(7):884-93
Faculty of Medicine,
University of Newcastle, Australia.
A modeling study was
undertaken to determine the effects of flexion on the forces
exerted by the
lumbar back muscles.
Twenty-nine fascicles of the lumbar multifidus and erector
spinae were
plotted onto tracings of
radiographs of nine normal volunteers in the flexion position.
Moment
arms and force vectors of each
fascicle were calculated. The model revealed that moment arms
decreased slightly in length
resulting in no more than an 18% decrease in maximum extensor
moments exerted across the
lumbar spine. Compression loads were not significantly
different
from those generated in the
upright posture. However, there were major changes in shear
forces,
in particular a reversal
from a net anterior to a net posterior shear force at the
L5/S1 segment.
Flexion causes substantial
elongation of the back muscles, which must therefore reduce
their
maximum active tension.
However, if increases in passive tension are considered it
emerges that
the compression forces and
moments exerted by the back muscles in full flexion are not
significantly different from
those produced in the upright posture.
Erector spinae activation and
movement dynamics about the lumbar spine in lordotic and
kyphotic squat-lifting.
Holmes JA, Damaser MS, Lehman
SL
Spine 1992 Mar;17(3):327-34
Department of Physical Education, University of California,
Berkeley.
Activation of the erector
spinae during squat lifts depends on the initial posture of
the lumbar
spine. The authors assessed
erector spinae activation by electromyography during squat
lifts from
lordotic and kyphotic
postures, measured kinematics of the lifts from digitized
video images, and
inferred torques from the
kinematics, using a two-dimensional model of a human lifting
in the
sagittal plane, with a joint
at L3. Lifts from the lordotic initial posture had peak
electromyographic
signals early in the lift,
whereas lifts from kyphotic initial posture had an initial
"flexor relaxation,"
and peak activity in the
middle of the lift. Lumbar flexion was much greater in lifts
from kyphotic
initial position. Torques
required about L3 were similar between the two postures,
though
somewhat larger initially in
lifts from kyphosis. The largest torques were therefore
sustained by
flexed lumbar spines, during
periods of little or no erector spinae activity, in lifts made
from
kyphotic initial position. A
sizable portion of the early torque is inertial, and therefore
strongly
dependent on movement time.
Movements with a 30-lb load in the hands were similar, in
kinematics and
electromyography, to unloaded lifts, though longer in
duration. The clinical
implications of the
differences in activation with posture, the practical
implications of the inertial
component of torque, and the
need for consideration of lumbar posture in future modeling of
squat lifting are discussed.
Lumbar lordosis. Effects of
sitting and standing
Lord MJ, Small JM, Dinsay
JM, Watkins RG
. Spine 1997 Nov
1;22(21):2571-4
Kerlan-Jobe Orthopaedic Clinic, Inglewood, California, USA.
STUDY DESIGN: The effect of
sitting versus standing posture on lumbar lordosis was studied
retrospectively by
radiographic analysis of 109 patients with low back pain.
OBJECTIVE: To
document changes in
segmental and total lumbar lordosis between sitting and
standing
radiographs. SUMMARY OF
BACKGROUND DATA: Preservation of physiologic lumbar
lordosis is an important
consideration when performing fusion of the lumbar spine. The
appropriate degree of lumbar
lordosis has not been defined. METHODS: Total and segmental
lumbar lordosis from L1 to
S1 was assessed by an independent observer using the Cobb
angle
measurements of the lateral
radiographs of the lumbar spine obtained with the patient in
the sitting
and standing positions.
RESULTS: Lumbar lordosis averaged 49 degrees standing and 34
degrees sitting from L1 to S1,
47 degrees standing and 33 degrees sitting from L2 to S1, 31
degrees standing and 22
degrees sitting from L4 to S1, and 18 degrees standing and 15
degrees
sitting from L5 to S1.
CONCLUSION: Lumbar lordosis while standing was nearly 50%
greater
on average than sitting
lumbar lordosis. The clinical significance of this data may
pertain to: 1) the
known correlation of
increased intradiscal pressure with sitting, which may be
caused by this
decrease in lordosis; 2) the
benefit of a sitting lumbar support that increases lordosis;
and 3) the
consideration of an
appropriate degree of lordosis in fusion of the lumbar spine.
Effect of lumbar posture on
lifting.
Hart DL, Stobbe TJ,
Jaraiedi M
Spine 1987 Mar;12(2):138-45
Twenty laborers assumed
specific lumbar spine postures and lifted a 157 N crate to
three
different hand heights to
determine if lumbar spine flexion moments or trunk muscle
activity were
affected by the lifting
postures. Lumbar flexion moments were lowest when the workers
used the
lordotic and straight back
postures, while the average erector spinae muscle activity
tended to be
highest in the lordotic and
straight back postures. The kypohotic posture regularly
reduced the
activity of the erector
spinae to bursts of activity while lifting and caused more
discomfort during
the lifting tasks than any
other posture. Therefore, the lumbar lordotic posture is
recommended as
the posture of choice while
lifting, particularly when lifting from the floor level.
***************
Sagittal profiles of the
spine.
Voutsinas SA, MacEwen GD
Clin Orthop 1986
Sep;(210):235-42
The sagittal plane of the
growing spine was studied from standardized radiographs of 670
normal
subjects to establish
standards of reference for thoracic kyphosis, lumbosacral
lordosis, and
sacral inclination. Cobb's
method of measuring spinal deformities was compared with new
indices
of kyphosis and lordosis
that take into consideration the length and width of each
curve. Boys
and girls had comparable
degrees of kyphosis. Although girls initially had higher
degrees of
lordosis and sacral
inclination, by maturity these measurements were similar in
both sexes.
Significant correlations
were found between kyphosis and lordosis and between lordosis
and
sacral inclination, indicating
that these curvatures tend to balance each other.
On neck muscle activity and
load reduction in sitting postures. An electromyographic and
biomechanical study with applications in ergonomics and
rehabilitation.
Schuldt K
Scand J Rehabil Med Suppl
1988;19:1-49
Department of Physical
Medicine and Rehabilitation Karolinska Institute, Stockholm,
Sweden.
In this study of the
biomechanics and muscular function of the cervical spine,
skilled women
workers simulated standardized
electromechanical assembly work in eight sitting postures.
Normalized electromyography
was used to quantify activity in neck-and-shoulder muscles.
With
the whole spine flexed, muscle
activity in the cervical erector spinae, trapezius and
thoracic
erector spinae muscles was
higher than when the whole spine was straight and vertical.
The
posture with the trunk
slightly inclined backward and neck vertical gave the lowest
activity levels.
Flexed neck compared to
vertical neck gave higher activity in the cervical erector
spinae. Work
with abducted arm gave high
neck muscle activity. Work postures can thus be optimized to
diminish neck muscle load.
Two ergonomic acids were studied during the work cycle. Elbow
support reduced the activity
in the trapezius and thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids muscles
in the
posture with the whole spine
flexed and in the posture with the whole spine vertical. Arm
suspension gave mainly
similar reduction in these postures, and also a reduction in
the cervical
erector spinae. In the
position with the trunk slightly inclined backward, arm
suspension gave a
reduction in the trapezius.
These findings indicate that arm support or arm suspension can
be used
to reduce neck muscle load.
Three methodological studies related to neck muscle load and
normalization were included.
1) Examination of the effect of different isometric maximum
test
contractions on neck muscles
showed that all contractions activated all muscles studied,
including
those on the contralateral
side, to some extent and at various levels. The highest
frequency of
attained maximum levels
was: for neck extension, in cervical erector spinae; for
cervical spinae
lateral flexion, in splenius
and levator scapulae; for arm abduction, in trapezius, and,
for shoulder
elevation and scapular
retraction/elevation, in thoracic erector spinae/rhomboids.
Proximal
resistance gave higher
activity than distal. 2) The relationship between EMG activity
and muscular
moment was studied in women
during submaximal and maximum isometric neck extension. The
relationship found was
non-linear, with greater increase in activity at high moments
in the
posterior neck muscles
studied. The slightly flexed cervical spine position induced a
higher level
of activity in erector
spinae cervicalis than did the neutral position for a given
relative muscular
moment. 3) Muscular activity
was related to cervical spine position during maximum
isometric
neck extension. Peak
activity in the cervical erector spinae was found in the
slightly flexed
lower-cervical spine
position.
[A new surgical treatment for
syringomyelia, scoliosis, Arnold-Chiari
malformation, kinking of the
brainstem, odontoid recess, idiopathic basilar
impression and platybasia].
[Article in Spanish]
Royo-Salvador MB
1: Rev Neurol 1997
Apr;25(140):523-30
Servicio de Neurocirugia,
Clinica Tres Torres, Barcelona, Jefe del, Espana.
INTRODUCTION: Based on
medullary traction as responsible for idiopathic
syringomyelia (SMI),
idiopathic scoliosis (ESCID), Arnold Chiari malformation
(ARCH), platybasia (PTB),
basilar impression (IMB), odontoid recess (RTO)
kinking of the brain stem
(KTC) and considering the medullary traction to be
transmitted by the filum
terminale (FT), a surgical technique for the section of
FT (SFT) is described in three
cases of SMI, one of ESCID, and one of ARCH with
no lumbar dysraphia. MATERIAL
AND METHODS: A 34-year-old woman with
cervico-brachialgias,
paresthesias, bilateral babinski and a centro-medullary
cavity C3-C7. A 26-year-old
male with cervico-brachialgias, hypoestesia in left
hemybody, and cervicobulbar
cavity. A 19-year-old female with ESCID since the
age of 14th, with episodes of
reacuting, and 38o of dorsolumbar curvature. A
67-year-old woman with intense
headache, hypoesthesia of the hands, paraparesia
and ARCH. A 23-year-old man
with marked tetraparesia, bilateral babinski,
anesthesia of both legs, SMI,
ESCID, ARCH and hydrocephaly. RESULTS: After SFT:
in the SMIs the
thermo-algesic, disesthetic and algic dissociation
disappeared.
In ESCID there was a reduction
to 31o in the curvature in nine months. On ARCH
the headaches ceased and there
was recovery of touch and paraparesia.
CONCLUSIONS: SFT is a useful
etiological treatment for SMI, ESCID, ARCH. Also,
in ESCID it is possible to
avoid stress on the medulla due to its surgical
reduction.
PMID: 9172910, UI: 97287994
Sagittal alignment in
lumbosacral fusion: relations between radiological parameters
and pain
J-Y. Lazennec, S. Ramaré, N.
Arafati, C. G. Laudet, M. Gorin, B. Roger, S. Hansen, G.
Saillant, L. Maurs, R.
Trabelsi
European Spine Journal Volume
9 Issue 1 (2000) pp 47-55
Service de Chirurgie
Orthopédique et Traumatologique, Hôpital Pitie-Salpetrière 83,
Boulevard de l'Hôpital,
F-75013 Paris, France (Tel.: +33-1-42 17 70 61, Fax: +33-1-42
17 70 62)
(2) Department of
Anatomy, Faculty of the Pitié-Salpetrière Hospital, Paris,
France
(3) Clinique
Radiologique, Paris, France
(4) Central Radiology
Department, Pitié-Salpetrière Hospital, Paris, France
(5) Pr Lyon-Caen et
Agid Neurological Department, Salpetrière Hospital, Paris,
France
Received: 21 January
1999/Revised: 28 July 1999/Accepted: 17 September 1999
Abstract The objective
of this study was to conduct a radiological analysis of
posture
before and after
lumbosacral fusion to evaluate the influence of spinal
alignment on the
occurrence and pattern
of post surgical pain. The study included 81 patients, of whom
51
had a history of
previous low back surgery. We excluded patients with suspected
or
confirmed nonunion. In
the fusion group, the 27 patients who were pain free
after the procedure were compared to the 54 patients with
residual pain. Thirty patients had pain only or primarily when
they were standing immobile, 18 when they were sitting
immobile, and six in both positions. Measurements were done
on full-length lateral radiographs of the spine, with the
patient standing according to Duval
Beaupère criteria. The
subgroup with postfusion pain was characterized at baseline by
a
more vertical sacrum
with less sacral tilt (ST) (P < 0.0062) and more pelvic tilt
(PT) (P < 0.0160). PT at last follow-up (PT fu) correlated
with the presence of postfusion pain (NP: P = 0.0003). In the
patients with postfusion pain, PT was almost twice the normal
value. ST at last follow-up (ST fu) in the
standing position was
also correlated with the presence of postfusion pain (P <
0.0001)
indicating that the
sacrum remained abnormally vertical in the subjects with
postfusion pain. Using logistic regression, the only
prognostic factor for residual pain at last follow-up was ST
fu. Both at pre-operative evaluation and at last follow-up,
patients with pain in the standing position or in both the
standing and sitting
positions were characterized at pre-operative status by a more
vertical
sacrum with less sacral
tilt. The results of this study indicate that, achieving a
strong fusion
should not be the only
goal. Appropriate position of the fused vertebrae is also of
paramount importance to
minimize muscle work during posture maintenance. The main risk
is failing to correct
or to causing excessive pelvic retroversion with a vertical
sacrum leading
to a sagittal alignment
that replicates the sitting position. This situation is often
accompanied
by loss of lumbar
lordosis and adversely affects stiff or degenerative hips.
Key words Sacroiliac
joint · Lumbosacral fusion · Spinal alignment
European Spine Journal
Volume 8 Issue 6 (1999) pp 426-428
review: Why the back of
the child?
X. Phélip
Department of
Rheumatology, University Hospital of Grenoble, BP 217, F-38043
Grenoble Cedex, France
e-mail: xavier.phelip@ujf-grenoble.fr, Fax: +33-4 76 76 56 02
Received: 5 August 1999
Accepted: 18 August 1999
Abstract An
international congress about "the back of children and
teenagers and the
prevention of backache"
was held in March 1999 in Grenoble (France). Beside specific
low back pain following
progressive and growth diseases, special attention was paid to
non-specific low back
pain (LBP). Some epidemiological data show a high incidence of
LBP during and after
the rapid growth phase, with the concomitant possibility of
continued
or recurrent evolution.
MRI studies reveal frequent signs of disc degeneration: they
start
after the growth phase,
spread during adolescence and are often correlated with
backache.
An immunohistological
study seems to confirm the presence of degenerative-type
alterations and changes
in collagen in the vertebral plates and nucleus of juvenile
spine.
These data must be
confirmed, and their relation to natural history and prognosis
of juvenile
LBP have to be
clarified by longitudinal studies.
Low back pain in a
population of school children
R. Gunzburg (1), F.
Balagué (2), M. Nordin (3), M. Szpalski (4), D. Duyck (5), D.
Bull
(1), C. Mélot (6)
European Spine Journal Volume
8 Issue 6 (1999) p p 439-443
(1) Eeuwfeestkliniek,
Harmoniestraat 68, 2018 Antwerp, Belgium
(2) Fribourg Cantonal
Hospital, Switzerland
(3) Occupational and
Industrial Orthopaedic Center, New York, New York, USA
(4) Molière Longchamps
Hospital, Brussels, Belgium
(5) Medical School
Inspection, Antwerp, Belgium
(6) Erasme University
Hospital, Brussels, Belgium
Received: 7 June 1999
Revised: 23 September 1999 Accepted: 8 November 1999
Abstract A study was
undertaken to analyse the prevalence of low back pain (LBP)
and
confounding factors in
primary school children in the city of Antwerp. A total of 392
children aged 9 were
included in the study. All children completed a validated
three-page
questionnaire and they
all underwent a specific lumbar spine oriented medical
examination
during their annual
routine medical school control. This examination was performed
by the
city school doctors.
The questionnaire was composed of easy "yes/no" questions and
visual
analogue scales.
Statistical analysis was performed using Student's t-test and
chi-squared
test at the
significance level P < 0.05. The prevalence of LBP was high.
No gender
difference was found. A
total of 142 children (36%) reported having suffered at least
one
episode of LBP in their
lives. Of these, 33 (23%) had sought medical help for LBP from
a
doctor or
physiotherapist. Sixty-four percent of children reporting LBP
said that at least
one of their parents
suffered from or complained of LBP. This was significantly
higher than
|